Friday, October 4, 2019

Welcome to the Mountains of North Carolina – 9 New Statebirds and Counting, September, 2019


After 26 years living in New England, I’ve moved to the mountains of western North Carolina.  I’ve really enjoyed my birding time in the northeast, and it’s certainly tough to leave behind all my birding friends, and all those great birds and birding spots back there.  I’ll especially miss my time at the coast, with the closest coastline being just an hour and 15 minutes away.  Over the years I was able to amass 2,077 “total ticks” in the 6 New England states.  However, as a result, I was a victim of my own successes with very few regular species to hope for as potential new statebirds.  Plus even the rarities were becoming few and far between. 

So now it’s time to start learning about the birds of my new region.  Similar to New England, there are a number of states nearby - I’m only about 30 minutes from the SC stateline, an hour from TN, and within 2 hours of northern GA.  So once I can get settled in, I can begin to focus on the southern Appalachians in general and not just western NC.  One key difference I will need to get used to is my limited access to the coast, with the nearest coastline about 3 ½ hours away.  Although coastal trips are still feasible, especially as part of a 2- or 3-day trip to search for multiple targets, it’s not likely that I will be heading to the coast to chase a single rarity like I could in much of New England. 

And speaking of targets, I have quite a number of them in my new area.  My lists in each of the states in the region are already pretty good -
              North Carolina – 251
              South Carolina – 232
              Tennessee – 237
              Georgia – 233

But in each case I’m only a little over the old ABA reportable threshold (half of the total statelist) – my TN list is the best at 33 over the threshold.  By comparison, when I left New England I was between 90 and 170 over the ABA thresholds in each of the 6 New England states.  Obviously I have many more possible statebirds in the southeast than in New England, including a number of relatively easy ones.  

I haven’t done a lot of birding yet in my new area, but I’ve already added 9 new species to my NC list.  The first two were while on a house-hunting trip in April – Broad-winged Hawk and Cerulean Warbler.  On that trip, with next to no real birding time, I had more than 60 species as we visited open houses throughout the region,

By far most of my NC birding so far has been in my own yard.  I live on the side of heavily wooded mountain (Lewis Mountain) in Hendersonville, which is surrounded by agricultural land.  My lot has woods on two sides and I’ve found many migrants passing through the yard especially along those wooded edges.  Perhaps the mountain is enough of an oasis of woodlands to concentrate the migrants.  In the first month living here I’ve accumulated a yard list of 70 species, including 17 warbler species.  Four have been new for my NC state list - Blue-winged Warbler, Mississippi Kite, Yellow-bellied Flycatcher, and Golden-winged Warbler.  The Kites were perhaps my favorite sighting – a flock of 16 birds that migrated by high overhead.

There are also a number of good birding spots just a short drive away.  For instance, I’ve made a few stops at a nearby sod farm, and have found a Buff-breasted Sandpiper and two American Golden-Plovers, both new for my statelist.  Plus I’ve attended a couple field trips for the local Audubon chapter- adding Bay-breasted Warbler as a new statebird on one of those trips (I later had several in my yard).  And I can’t wait to start exploring the hotspots in the higher elevations in the mountains. 

Several of my new NC statebirds were relatively common species that I hope to be able to add in other states nearby.  For instance, I still need Golden-winged Warbler in South Carolina and Georgia as a regular migrant and a local breeder (see my statebird map below).  By comparison it was quite a rarity in New England.


Whereas there were others like Mississippi Kite where NC was one of the last states in the region where I still needed that species.


That brings me up to 260 in NC, and counting…

Saturday, September 14, 2019

Moving to the Mountains of North Carolina – Thanks for the New England Memories, August 2019


After 26 years in New England I’ve retired to the mountains of western North Carolina.  I’ve had a great time birding throughout New England, and greatly appreciate all the help provided by birders throughout the region!  I was able to amass a total of 2,077 “total ticks” and 441 species in the 6 New England states over the years – second only to the late Denny Abbott.  Years ago I adopted Denny’s goal of reaching 2,000 New England ticks, which drove me to chase after new potential statebirds almost anywhere throughout the region.  But I became a victim of my own successes.  The number of new possible statebirds in New England had dwindled dramatically recently and were almost strictly limited to rarities, which of course were completely unpredictable, and often required long drives.  
But now I can look forward to working on my statelists in NC and beyond.  Like New England, there are a number of states nearby.  I’ve moved to Hendersonville, NC, which is only about 20 minutes from the SC state line, an hour from TN, and about 90 minutes from GA.  I’ve got pretty good lists in each of these states, but there is still lots of potential!  One species I’m especially looking forward to learning about is the Swainson’s Warbler that breeds in the mountainous rhododendron thickets – I’ve never seen them in that habitat.  I need that species in each state in the region, except for NC.  But that’s for my next blog post.
For now, a bit of reminiscing after 26 years of birding in New England -

NH – 370 statelist
Although I birded extensively throughout New England, I’m especially proud of my NH list, starting with finding a Townsend’s Warbler at Odiorne Point SP on 11/21/93, just a couple months after I moved to New England.  Other fond memories - 
  • Almost any trip to the coast, whether it was to chase after a rarity (like Sabine’s Gull – 7/8/09, Brown Pelican – 6/24/17, and of course the Shelduck - 8/19/17), or just general birding for migrant passerines and shorebirds. Though on my first trip to the coast in August 1993 I realized that you need town stickers on the car to park in many locations (an expensive ticket at Eel Pond opened my eyes to that requirement).  
  • Pelagic and whale watch trips, including trying to figure out which state each bird was in.  And my favorites were those birds that NH birders thought were in NH while MA birders thought were in MA. 
  • Many trips to pumpkin patches for fall sparrows in Hollis quite close to home.

MA – 415 state list
I birded nearly the entire state from east to west – from Race Point and the Yellow-billed Loon on 3/7/16 (with 4 loon species in the same binocular field), to Great Barrington and the Allen’s Hummingbird on 11/7/12.  Other memories along the way - 
  • White-tailed Tropicbird and Sooty Tern at Quabbin Reservoir on 8/28/11 after the passage of Hurricane Irene
  • Adult Ivory Gull at Gloucester on 1/18/09 right after a snowstorm – the Gull was whiter than the new-fallen snow
  • Red-footed Falcon on 8/14/04 on Martha’s Vineyard with hundreds of other birders
  • And a Pepperell yard list of 143 species featuring rarities like Summer Tanager, Cerulean Warbler, Hooded Warbler, Acadian Flycatcher and Wheatear.

VT – 282 statelist
Although some of the best VT birding was a long drive from home, limiting my chases and keeping my list under 300, I still enjoyed lots of fond birding memories like –
  • “Pelagic trips” on Lake Champlain with Little Gull (10/19/13) and Sabine’s Gull (9/9/17)
  • Annual Fall passerine migrant trips to the southeast part of the state finding a Connecticut Warbler (9/27/16) and Blue Grosbeak (10/12/18) – though I never caught up with an Orange-crowned Warbler
  • Seeing a Yellow-crowned Night Heron by flashlight at Bomoseen SP on 8/31/15 (on my 3rd try)
  • Slowly ticking off all those shorebird species difficult to find in this inland state, at places like the Colchester Causeway, Goose Bay, Dead Creek, etc.  And then birding Goose Bay in route to fall shorebirding at Baie Missisquoi just across the Quebec line.
  • Poring through goose flocks in Vernon to find Cackling and Barnacle Geese (3/28/07) -though I couldn’t pick out the Barnacle after it and the rest of the flock flew out over NH airspace
  • Those large Snow Goose flocks, with an occasional Ross’s, in Addison
  • Finding Grebe and Scoter flocks on inland lakes during migration.  Not to mention rarer “coastal” waterfowl like Harlequin Duck (3/23/06) and King Eider (11/30/17)

CT – 333 statelist
CT highlights were many, including -
  • Hammonasset Beach SP was by far my favorite location, where I added 23 new birds to my state list over the years with rarities like Lazuli Bunting (1/24/07) and California Gull (3/23/16) and a spectacular pelagic display with Cory’s and Great Shearwaters and Parastic Jaegers on 8/15/18
  • Multiple “pelagic trips” on the ferries out of New London with shearwaters, jaegers, and alcids in CT and NY waters – including a rare Pomarine Jaeger in both states crossing the stateline along with the ferry
  • Many trips to Milford Point including rarities like White-tailed Kite (8/21/10) and Roseate Spoonbill (9/22/18)
  • And then finally seeing Yellow-headed Blackbird at UConn (1/3/19), after missing this species 3 other times in CT

ME – 343 statelist
Some of my fondest memories in Maine include –
  • Numerous trips to Biddeford – with migrant passerines and Kentucky Warbler (9/9/13) in the woods, Caspian Tern (7/26/17) and Royal Terns (7/11/14) on Hills Beach, Oystercatchers (7/17/04) in the Pool, Surfbird (3/22/15) on the rocks, and Pacific Loon (11/22/14) offshore.
  • Scarborough Marsh with rarities like European Golden-Plover (10/11/08), Little Egret (6/29/11), and Black-necked Stilt (6/22/13), not to mention great studies of the marsh sparrows – Seaside, Saltmarsh, and Nelson’s
  • Goose flocks in Yarmouth including Cackling, White-fronted and Barnacle (all on 10/7/08), and Pink-footed (10/20/09).
  • Seeing the Red-billed Tropicbird (7/28/12) on my 4th try, but not without a 7-hour round-trip drive, a ride on a passenger ferry, a ride on a modified crabbing boat, and an overnight stay on an off-shore island.
  • Western Grebe in Brunswick more than a mile away (4/23/16) – as the locals put it – “wicked faahh”

RI – 334 statelist
Especially in the most recent years I birded in RI more than any other state, often looking for rarities on my own rather than chasing after those reported earlier.  My best memories over the years -
  • My first ever trip to RI in 1993 when I planned to bird at “Quixen Pond”, but I couldn’t find it on the map (well before smart phones and map apps).  Then with the help of some local shop owners I found out it was actually “Quicksand Pond” I was looking for – my first experience with those New England accents
  • Black-tailed Gull in Middletown on 7/11/95- the lifebird was worth the expensive parking ticket for not being a town resident
  • A 7-goose day on 1/13/07 including Barnacle, Pink-footed, Cackling, and White-fronted
  • Many trips to Trustom Pond – including the Townsend’s Warbler on 11/27/17
  • Numerous sea watches at Camp Cronin, Point Judith and Moonstone Beach featuring a Brown Pelican, Parasitic Jaeger, and Sooty Tern after the passage of Hurricane Irene (9/1/11), and a flyby South Polar Skua (9/9/17) after Hurricane Jose 
  • Talking my way into gaining access to private property in Little Compton to see a Northern Lapwing on 2/7/13
  • Taking the ferry back and forth to Block Island many times on what I called a “poor man’s pelagic”, not to mention winter sea watches from the southern tip of the island and lots of Guillemots 
  • Tennessee Warbler in the Lonsdale Marshes on 5/11/15 – my 2,000th “Total Tick” for New England
  • And then finally catching up with Mississippi Kite in East Greenwich on 5/26/19

Then there are some interstate memories featuring –
  • Adding 3 species to my lists in 3 different states in the same day – Sandwich Tern in MA, White Ibis in NH, and Royal Tern in ME – all on 7/11/14

And then finally the ultimate, which I dubbed “my best 2 days of birding ever” –
  • 8/9/18 - Great Black Hawk in ME (2nd ABA record and 1st in New England), Neotropic Cormorant in NH (1st New England Record), and Wood Stork in NH (1st accepted NH record)
  • 8/10/18 – Little Egret in RI (2nd state record), and Bridled Tern as a life bird on Great Gull Island in NY – after missing it twice in CT the previous year.

New England – thanks for the memories!

Now it’s on to the Carolinas…

Thursday, May 30, 2019

Upland Sandpiper, Richmond, RI, May 2019

Upland Sandpiper is a rare migrant through New England, and a recent nester only in a few grassland locations in MA, NH, and ME.  In RI, this species is rare in migration, with just 3 eBird sightings in the last decade – one in spring and 2 in fall.  Most sightings occur at the sod farms in the southern part of the state, along with the slightly more likely Buff-breasted Sandpipers and regular (in fall) Golden Plovers.  I’ve been able to catch up with Buff-breasts and Golden Plovers in RI over the years.  But the Uplands have been a different story – not only are they rare but most sightings have been one-day wonders which I didn’t chase after.  And the only one I did go for was seen for just 2 days – I tried for it on day 3. 

Then on April 24, 2019 came a report of an Upland at the sod fields in Slocum, RI.  Although this bird was once again only seen for that one day, there was a report of another Upland on the 25th along Heaton Orchard Road in Richmond.  (Or I guess there was a chance that this was the same bird visiting the 2 sites 7 miles apart “as the Sandpiper flies”.)  I wasn’t thinking about chasing after this one since it too was likely to be a one-day wonder.  But then came reports that the bird was continuing the next day, and then the next.  Unfortunately, I was super busy at home with no time to try for one of the few truly chaseable Upland Sandpipers in RI in recent memory.

I finally had a window of opportunity to try for the Upland on May 2nd or 3rd.  I had planned a birding trip to eastern CT on the 2nd and RI on the 3rd with birding friend Blair Bernson of WA.  Blair was on a quest to see 50 species in each of the 50 states, and I was helping him out in CT and RI.  In theory I could swing by the sod farms either of those days, but wasn’t too optimistic that this bird would still be around by the time I could finally get to the area – 7 or 8 days after it was first reported.  However, amazingly, the sightings continued and the bird was apparently quite reliable.  So I crossed my fingers that I could successfully add a stop at the Heaton Orchard Road sod farms to my pre-planned CT/RI trip itinerary.

Our CT birding on the 2nd went exceptionally well – in fact better than expected.  We ended our day at Hammonasset Beach State Park where a planned brief stop turned into a 3-hour visit as we ran into a tremendous fallout of migrant passerines, giving us well over 100 species on the day.  But that cut into my time to try for the Upland.  I only had time for a brief stop there that evening, but would have much more time the next day.  Not wanting to take a chance on whether the bird would stay yet another day, I decided to head to Richmond for a brief stop on evening of the 2nd to give it a go.

Several posts mentioned that the bird was being seen in the fields east of telephone poles 43, 44, and 45 – can’t get much more specific than that.  So as I pulled onto Heaton Orchard Road from the north I started scanning the numbers on the poles, and pulled over between poles 44 and 45 to start my search.  A quick binocular scan to the east netted no birds at all.  I suddenly remembered how big the sod farms were – roughly a square mile of likely habitat.  A sinking feeling started to set in as I started to wonder whether I would actually be able to find this one bird in so many acres of habitat.  But then I remembered one post that the bird was frequenting the taller grass – which was actually in the closer fields.  I had been looking farther out which happened to be the shorter grass.  So I changed my focus to these nearer fields, and with the next scan I quickly found the target Upland Sandpiper no more than 100 feet from me.  I got this phonescoped photo of this most cooperative bird.


This bird continued to be seen in this same sod farm through May 4th – 10 consecutive days.  During most of this time the weather was cool, gray, often rainy, and rarely with any southerly winds.  Maybe that’s why it decided to make such a long stop in RI on its way to a breeding site somewhere to the north.

Upland Sandpiper was #333 for my RI list.  In my statebird map below the 31 dark-shaded states are those where I’ve seen this species; the cross-hatched states are those where Upland is regular though not yet on my statelists. 


Monday, May 6, 2019

Trumpeter Swan (But is it Countable?), April 2019, Candia NH


I was working outside in the garden early on Sunday morning 4/14 when I received a text from NH birder Steve Mirick that the Trumpeter Swan was continuing in Candia.  Trumpeter Swan?  What Trumpeter Swan?  I hadn’t seen any posts about what might be the first modern-day record of Trumpeter Swan in NH.  I came inside to check e-mails, and with some research noticed that the bird was first spotted the day before but initially reported as a Tundra Swan.  I don’t need Tundra for my NH list so it didn’t pop up in an eBird Needs Alert.  And with less people using the listserves, it wasn’t until the text the next day that the news got out in a big way.

Now I needed to free up some time to chase after the Swan.  Often Trumpeters will stick around for a while, so I wasn’t too worried that I couldn’t leave right away to chase after it.  Instead I planned to give it a try right after church.  I did a bit more research and found that the bird was being seen in the wetlands of the Abe Emerson Marsh Wildlife Sanctuary, and then downloaded a map of the trails at the site.  That was just a 45-minute drive away – less than half the distance of most of my normal New England chases.  I coordinated with NH birder David Donsker and it sounded like we would both arrive at about the same time.  More eyes the better.

By the time I left church there were a couple more posts, including photos of the bird swimming close by the photographer.  And while in route I called another NH birder David Deifik to make sure he knew about the bird.  He had just seen the Swan but it wasn’t in view at the time.  So I was optimistic though it might take a bit of searching.

I arrived at about 1 PM just as yet another NH birder Davis Finch got to the site (after all it could be a first recent NH record – everyone was descending on the site!).  Davis said he saw the bird as he passed by the marsh on Route 101; it was same story from David Donsker who had just arrived.  But stopping on the highway is likely to be frowned upon by local police, so we all started our searches from the trails in the sanctuary.  After about 20 minutes of increasingly anxious searching Davis and I finally spotted the Swan at the far southern end of the wetlands.  We were on the northeastern water’s edge about 1,000 ft away, and the bird was at least partially obscured, so the sighting wasn’t the best.  But we were able to get occasional views of the head/bill shape to ensure the ID and eliminate Tundra Swan.

Now the question was whether this bird could be countable in NH.  There is apparently one historical NH record of Trumpeter Swan, based on an account in "History of New Hampshire" by Jeremy Belknap written in 1792.  As a result, this species is on the NH state list based solely on the summary contained in that 200-year-old book.  But since then, Trumpeters had been extirpated from virtually all of their former range, and in fact hunted to near extinction.  That was until very successful re-introduction programs were begun in the 1980s in several Midwest states and Ontario.  This species is now successfully breeding in many locations throughout this region, including birds breeding as close as the Finger Lakes region of NY. 

Not surprisingly Trumpeters are showing up in increasing frequency in New England, and recent sightings have been deemed to be countable from viable re-introduced populations by the rare bird committees of VT, CT, RI, and MA.  At least one set of photos of the Candia bird showed that it was not banded, and had no wingtags, so the NH bird is not likely to be an escapee, and most likely from these re-introduced populations.  It will be up to the NH Rare Bird Committee to decide if this bird is indeed countable, but it would sure seem that based on the recent countable records elsewhere in New England, that the Committee members will decide to count this record as well.

If accepted by the NHRBC it would be number 370 for my NH list.  In my statebird map below, the 18 dark shaded states are those where I’ve seen Trumpeter Swan, including several midwestern states associated with the re-introduction program.  The cross-hatched states are those where this species is regular though I haven’t caught up with it yet.  I’ve also seen it in 2 Canadian provinces – BC and ON.  And with the increasing eastern populations Trumpeters will undoubtedly become regular in additional eastern states and provinces in the near future.


Sunday, April 28, 2019

Nine Winter Province Birds, Southern Quebec, March 2019


Over the years I’ve birded Quebec a number of times, always in the southern portion of the province crossing the border from northern NH, VT, or NY.  And most typically my trips have been in the warmer months of June through September.  I’ve avoided mid-winter birding there given how cold and snowy it can be in winter in this inland Canadian province.  But to have a good Quebec list you can’t completely avoid birding in those cold winter months.  As a compromise I birded southern Quebec in November 2015 picking up a number of winter species including Tree Sparrow, Common Redpoll, Rough-legged Hawk, and multiple species of waterfowl. 

But that still left numerous gaps in my province list consisting of species that are almost only seen in those cold mid-winter months.  Plus, since I’ve never birded anywhere in Canada in mid-winter, several of these would be new for my entire Canada list.  Not to mention my Quebec list was at 198 – sure would be nice to exceed 200.  So now with lots of spare time on my hands, I decided to plan a mid-March trip to Quebec.  That is assuming I could find a 3-day window of time with no precipitation and temps that aren’t too cold.  Luckily the long-term forecasts predicted some promising weather March 12 to 14, so the stars were starting to align. 

Now it was time to start my planning efforts.  I came up with a realistic list of nearly 20 targets, including some pretty exciting winter birds like Bohemian Waxwing, Pine Grosbeak, Snowy Owl, and Hoary Redpoll.  Plus a few other rarer species that are out of season (White-crowned Sparrow), or rare for the area (Gray Partridge and Black-backed Woodpecker).  I typically hope to find maybe half of my targets on these types of trips, and on this one I expected to be able to add perhaps 8 or 9 species to my Quebec list.  I then reached out to my good birding friend David Donsker and he agreed to join me on this cross-border adventure.  He had not birded in Quebec before, so everything would be a new species for him. 

March 12 – Day 1

David and I headed out just after lunch on the 12th, and given the 4+ hour ride to the border, we would only have a couple hours of daylight to bird on Day 1.  To maximize our birding time the plan was to bird the agricultural fields just across the border from VT, with multiple targets seen throughout the area – Snow Bunting, Snowy Owl, Wild Turkey, and Lapland Longspur.  But perhaps our key target was the rare Gray Partridge recently seen in small numbers frequenting a small area of fields and homesteads. 

As we neared the border we twice spotted flocks of Turkeys feeding in fields in northern VT, so we hoped that would bode well for at least this one target once we got into Quebec.  Luckily our wait to get through customs was minimal, so we crossed the border just after 5.  And within just a couple minutes we spotted a large flock of Snow Buntings along the roadside – Province bird #1 and new for my Canada list as well – a great start. 

Next we reached Route 35 where a number of Snowy Owls had been reported recently.  Our plan was to drive along as slowly as possible on this busy road keeping our eyes open for a Snowy Owl along the way.  The fields were snow covered, so finding a white bird on a white background at 50 mph (or 80 km/hr) created a nearly impossible scenario for us, and we struck out at this first location.  But this was just the first of many locations where Snowy’s had been reported recently, so we weren’t too worried. 

We then headed toward the area where the Partridges had been reported, and as we drove along a small back road named Rang du Grand Bois, David yelled – “Turkeys!”.  It took a couple minutes to find a safe spot to turnaround, but soon we were back at the spot and there was a flock of 6 Turkeys feeding in the ag field nearby – province bird #2.  That meant we wouldn’t have to make stops at a couple other spots where Turkeys had been reported, freeing us up to spend more time looking for our other targets.

As we neared the Partridge location we came upon a small group of Horned Larks on the shoulder of Rang des Soixante.  Just as we started to scan them they all took off out over the snow covered field.  Luckily I had rolled down my window to try for a better view because I was able to hear the telltale rattle call of at least 1 Lapland Longspur mixed in with the higher pitched calls from the Larks (province bird #3).  Unfortunately we never saw the bird, and David was unable to hear it since he was on the other side of the car.  We waited a while, and a nice group of 20 Snow Buntings soon landed along the same exposed road shoulder, but the Longspur and Larks never returned. 

A couple more miles down the road we reached the area where the Gray Partridges had been seen –a small flock had been spotted numerous times along a diamond of roadsides, fields, and homesteads.  Though despite 3 slow tours around the diamond, we couldn’t come up with them.  The reports were now about a week old, so maybe they had moved on.  A consolation was finding a nice mixed flock of Buntings and Larks along a roadside with some extended (though distant) views of a Longspur mixed in. 

It was now getting dark and we called it quits, making our way to the highway to head to our hotel.  But then while driving along Route 10, up ahead we both spotted a bump on a light pole on the highway.  It was far enough away that we weren’t sure if it was even a bird.  As we got closer, we could tell it was a perched raptor, and as we passed almost directly below it, we could see that it was a Snowy Owl.  Here’s a picture of the roadway just after we confirmed the Snowy.

 

What a way to end the day – 4th new province bird, and new for my Canada list. 

March 13 – Day 2

Our first stop of the day was at Centre Ecologique Fernand-Seguin where there had been multiple reports of Hoary Redpolls, and two overwintering adult White-crowned Sparrows.  Although one can be skeptical of the quality of Hoary ID’s, there were photos included in several of the eBird reports that looked good.  Both the Redpolls and Sparrows were coming to feeders at the park – but there were apparently multiple feeders with limited details on the locations of each.  Looks like we would have to do a bit of research when we get to the park.

Luckily when we arrived one of the first things we spotted was a park map.  But the trails were a bit confusing, and we weren’t quite sure which feeder to head to.  As we stood there scratching our heads, a worker from the park office (which wasn’t even open yet), walked over to us to offer help.  She told us which feeders both of our targets frequented, and how to get to these feeders.  We couldn’t have asked for better local directions!

Our first destination was the Swallow Feeder preferred by the Redpolls.  After a short walk through the woods we could see a clearing up ahead, with a pole-mounted feeder.  There were birds swirling about – a large flock of Redpolls.  And the first bird we both put in our binocs was one perched on the feeder – it was a Hoary Redpoll (province bird #5, and new for Canada).  We watched as the Redpolls flew all around us, sometimes flying mere feet from us.  They were feeding on the ground, in the shrubs, and on the feeder.  And there were multiple birds singing – I’ve never heard singing Redpolls outside of birds on their breeding grounds in Alaska.  Over the next 15-20 minutes we estimated that we had at least 3 Hoary’s in with the flock of at least 50 Commons.  Could have been even more.  

Redpoll feeder

Although we hated to leave the Redpoll show, it was on to search for the White-crowned Sparrows which were being seen at the Chickadee Feeder.  After a short walk we came to this next feeder, where a photographer was already waiting.  We watched Chickadees come and go, and a few Redpolls as well, but no sparrows.  After a few minutes David noticed a bird skulking nearby which was a nice adult White-crowned Sparrow (province bird #6).  Often wintering White-crowns in New England will be immatures so it was a bit surprising that this one was an adult.  An excellent start to the day!

Next we were off to Technoparc Montreal and the adjacent Dorval Golf Course where there had been many reports of roosting owls – Short-eared, Great Horned, Long-eared, and Saw-whet, plus occasional Northern Shrike reports.  The details were a bit sketchy, but I was finally able to figure out that most all of the owl sightings were at the golf course, even though most were entered into eBird at the Technoparc hotspot.  Unfortunately when we arrived at the golf course we found out that it had recently been closed to the public since walking through the now melting snow cover could result in damage to the turf.  And we never found any places to bird at the Technoparc.  Frustrating…

The next stop was the eBird hotspot called Campus Macdonald where numerous Bohemian Waxwings had been recently reported.  Unfortunately here too the spot(s) where the Waxwings were being seen couldn’t have been the location of the hotspot, which was in the middle of ag fields for a university.  Instead we poked around one set of university buildings adjacent to the fields thinking this could be the spot, but never found any fruiting trees.  Then we noticed signs for another part of the university campus a short distance away, so we though we’d give that a try.  That part of the campus was very congested with cars and pedestrian students, complicated by roads narrowed by large snow and ice piles.  After driving around for a while we finally found a small group of fruiting crabapple trees that looked to be likely candidates, but there were no frugivores in sight.  After a great start we had come up completely empty on our next two locations. 

Hoping for better luck, we headed to Barrage (dam in French) du Grand-Moulin, which was a small backwater on the Riviere des Mille Iles where several Glaucous and occasional Iceland Gulls had been reported.  Interestingly, in this part of Quebec the most common wintering gull is typically the Great Black-backed, followed by Glaucous, then Herring, Iceland, and lastly Ring-billed.  To get to the viewing spot we had to navigate around large snow and ice piles, and then take a short walk in waist-deep snow.  Finally we got to the overlook, only to find less than 10 gulls on the water – just GBBG and Herring.  Was this going to be yet another strikeout?  Then we noticed a small group of gulls fly in to bathe on the river.  Then another small flock.  As more small groups came in we soon had critical mass and the first adult Glaucous Gull flew in (province bird #7).  More birds kept pitching in, and eventually we found 3 adult and 1 1st/2nd year Glaucous.  And just before we were going to leave, David spotted an adult Iceland (province bird #8).

Although the birds were distant I took these phonescoped shots of one of the adult Glaucous Gulls, perched near the left edge of the ice partially obscured.  After I got home and looked more closely at the photos I noticed an adult gull in the water a short distance to the left of the Glaucous, which appears smaller than a Herring, and a bit darker backed.  If only we had noticed it when we were there we could have focused our attention on this bird to try to turn it into a California.




Now that we were back in the “win column” we hoped our success would continue at the intersection of Rue d’Ivry et Avenue JJ Joubert in a rather urban portion of Laval Island to try for Pine Grosbeaks.  There had been daily reports of a flock here at a church through 3/9, but there had been no reports (positive or negative) since then.  Unfortunately there were no birds of any type when we arrived at the church – at least it was a small site and it only took us a few minutes to realize we were too late for our target. 

So we quickly headed to our last stop of the day - Cimetieres Mt-Royal and Notre-Dame-des-Neiges in Montreal where both Bohemian Waxwings and Pine Grosbeaks had been occasionally reported.  I birded this site a few years ago and remembered that the cemeteries are full of fruit trees, so we hoped to finally be successful finding these targets on our 3rd try.  After getting some directions at the office, we started a slow ride through the cemetery.  Roughly a half hour into our search we spotted a small group of 11 Robins roosting in a deciduous tree.  And then with a more detailed look we spotted 3 Bohemian Waxwings in the flock (province bird #9, and also new for Canada).  There was also a Cedar Waxwing mixed in, which is rarer than Bohemians in this area in winter.  Elsewhere in the cemetery we found another flock of 7 Robins, but no more Waxwings, and no Grosbeaks.  Interestingly, an eBirder reported a Pine Grosbeak there that day, but no Robins or Waxwings.

Day 3 – March 14

The key stop of the day was at the Bois Bon Air woodlands in the northeast part of Laval Island to search for a Black-backed Woodpecker that had been in these woods for over a month.  Reports mentioned seeing the bird on the Deer Trail and near the marsh, but with no maps available on-line and no further instructions, David and I worried that we might not find the proper locations.  So the first thing we did when we arrived in the area was to ask for directions at a skimobile shop nearby.  They gave us a few suggestions to access the woods, though no further details on the Deer Trail or the marsh.  A few minutes later we were walking toward the suggested access point, and up ahead we saw that 2 birders had just arrived.  In somewhat broken English they said they knew where the bird was and would take us there.  Suddenly we were much more positive about our chances.  Despite this new-found optimism, and 3 hours walking through the deep snow, we never found our target bird.  We saw lots of trees that had been de-barked by the Black-back, but it wasn’t to be.  Here’s a shot typical of the woodlands we searched.


As we were leaving 2 other birders were just arriving; it turns out that they found the Woodpecker a couple hours later.  Go figure.

Little did we know that our luck would get no better the rest of the day.  Plus since we spent more time than planned at the Woodpecker spot, we had less time to bird other locations.  We made a stop at the Aeroport de St-Hubert to try for a recently reported Northern Shrike with no luck, though did find a nice Snowy Owl.  And one last stop at feeders that had daily reports of Pine Siskins mixed in with a Redpoll flock yielded just 2 Repolls.  Interestingly the best bird of the day was one of our last birds - an early Turkey Vulture that was a flyover as we neared the border.  It was also the only eBird rarity of the trip.

We ended the trip with 44 species - a respectable total for a late-winter trip to these inland locations.  And although we missed a number of our targets, I was very happy to add 9 to my Quebec list, which was roughly what I expected before the trip started.  My province list now stands at 207 which is 90% of the old ABA reportable threshold.  That makes Quebec my best Canadian province list based on percentage of total birds on the province list.  Plus 4 of these species were new for my overall Canada list, bringing my total to 379.  By comparison, my Lower 48 US list of 737 is nearly twice that total.  Needless to say there are a lot of species in south FL or TX that I’ll never see in Canada.

Sunday, March 17, 2019

Golden Eagle - But Just Barely, Montague, MA, February 2019


One of the best ways to find Golden Eagles in New England is to spend time at fall hawk watches and get lucky to see one of the small number of birds that pass by each year.  But I’ve never done much in the way of birding at fall hawk migration spots so my chances to find Golden Eagles as fall migrants have been limited.  The other option is to be able to find a wintering bird.  Often a wintering Golden will stick around in a general area for a few days, though these birds will frequently cover large areas and may not be very reliable.  However needless to say, even an unreliable wintering bird will be more chaseable than a fall migrant that’s just passing through.   

As a result of these challenges, I have a rather checkered history with Golden Eagle in New England.  On the positive side, I have seen this species in NH and VT based on the sighting of a single bird on 3/25/14.  The bird had been reported in VT the previous couple days, and I was lucky enough to not only find the bird, but also to watch it fly back and forth over the stateline to add it to both statelists (I happened to be standing in Vernon, VT at the time).  Can’t get much better than that!  At the other end of the spectrum was a frustrating fall sighting I had years earlier as I was birding on Mount Agamenticus in Maine.  The bird was very far to the west and little more than a speck, though it seemed like it could have been an immature Golden.  Then there was the 7-hour roundtrip I made up the Maine coast in January 2013 to Flood Brothers Dairy in Clinton for what was generally described as a reliable wintering bird.  Alas the bird was totally unreliable the day I was there.  Ugh. 

Then on February 15, 2019 came reports of a Golden Eagle in central MA in the town of Montague, feeding on a cow carcass with numerous Bald Eagles.  Two consecutive days of sightings and photographs meant that the Golden was quite reliable.  But I couldn’t get out until after church on the 17th, so I crossed my fingers that it would stick around till that afternoon.   

The actual location where the birds were feeding wasn’t very clear from the posts, but many sightings were from Will’s Ferry Rd.  So when I finally arrived in the area a bit before 2 PM, I drove right to Will’s Ferry Rd to begin my search.  And within a few seconds I saw a large mixed flock of Ravens and Crows milling about.  After just a few seconds I realized most of the activity was focused around a distant field which was the likely location of the carcass (maybe it was a good thing that a slight rise in the field obscured the actual site of the cow’s remains).  Then I started noticing a few Bald Eagles in the area – first one, then two more, then a group of at least six.  And just then I spotted a pair of Eagles flying low over the field – one seemed a bit smaller than the other.  Both then rose up to head to the distant tree line along the Connecticut River and the slightly smaller bird had a white tail with a dark terminal band, and white patches at the base of the primaries on the otherwise dark wings.  I had the Golden Eagle!  I watched it for just a few seconds before it went behind the trees, and then followed it along the river for a few more seconds, mostly obscured by the branches, until it disappeared in the distance to the southwest. 

Now I just waited for it to return to give me better looks.  But over the next 2 hours I never did see the Golden again.  Though I had great views of Bald Eagles, with 10 in view at one time.  Plus I had a calling Fish Crow to give me a sweep of the Corvids.  And a small flock of Redpolls feeding nearby was a nice addition. 

I have to admit that as I continued to wait in vain for the Golden Eagle I began to doubt my sighting.  On the negative side, no one else spotted the Golden that day, and my sighting was brief.  But I was able to see every key field mark except for the golden hind-neck.  And the bird seemed to be passing through the area and then flying off to the south down the Connecticut River, instead of feeding at the carcass.  In other words, perhaps it wasn’t in the area for long that day, giving other birders next to no time to spot it.  So rather than doubting my brief but good sighting, I decided to stick with my initial ID and added it to my MA statelist. 

Golden Eagle was number 415 for MA.  And although MA was my 20th state for this species (the dark shaded states in my statebird map below), I still need it in quite a number of other states especially in the eastern and central portions of its regular range (the cross-hatched states). 





Statebird map

Monday, February 25, 2019

“Sanitized for Your Protection” - Second MA Sighting of Trumpeter Swan, Milford, MA, February 2019


Have you ever checked into a motel and noticed a little ring of paper around the toilet seat printed with these words – “Sanitized for Your Protection”?  My good birding friend David Deifik has used this phrase though in a very different context.  Consider the situation most all of us have been in where, although we have a certain bird on our life lists, in the back of our mind we might question the ID, or maybe we just want to get a better view of that species in general.  Once we do get that more definitive view of the species in question we feel much better about having that bird on our list.  Hence our lists have been - “Sanitized for Your Protection”.  

I had an opportunity to “sanitize” my MA statelist a bit in February 2019 when a Trumpeter Swan was spotted with Mute Swans at the Milford Pond in Milford.  I already had this species on my MA list based on a sighting on 3/21/04 in Northampton, MA.  Undoubtedly both the 2004 and the 2019 birds were directly or indirectly associated with the re-introduction efforts occurring in the Great Lakes.  But it was only when I started reading about the reports of the 2019 bird that I realized that the Massachusetts Avian Records Committee (MARC) did not accept the 2004 bird because it was felt that the Great Lakes population was not yet self-sustaining.  So although there was no question about the ID of the 2004 bird, it was still not countable on your MA statelist if you wanted to “play by the rules” so to speak.  Instead, the first MA record of Trumpeter Swan to be accepted by MARC was a bird from Charlton in May 2018.  So if I wanted sanitize the Trumpeter Swan record on my MA list I needed to go see the Milford bird.  Assuming this bird ends up being accepted by MARC that is. 

The Trumpeter had been spotted daily since January 28, often associating with several Mute Swans.  And even though the pond froze over during that time, the Trumpeter Swan remained at the pond and was quite reliable.  Most importantly it was indicated in one post that sightings before 2018 weren’t countable, otherwise I would have continued to have a non-countable bird on my MA list.  So on February 5th I made the short trek to Milford Pond, followed the directions to park behind the NRG building on the western side of the pond, and then walked down toward Clark Island.  A couple hours earlier there was a post that the Trumpeter was sitting on the ice north of the island with a pair of Mute Swans, so I was quite optimistic. 

As I neared the island I got a glimpse of Swans out on the ice.  A quick binoc view yielded 3 birds – I likely had the Trumpeter and 2 Mutes but all were sleeping.  I needed a better view.  I walked along the trail on Clark Island and got to a spot where I was closest to the Swans.  From there scope views confirmed 2 Mute Swans now walking around on the ice a bit in the distance, and one closer Swan which was still asleep on the ice.  Undoubtedly this was the Trumpeter but I had to be sure – after all I was there to “sanitize” my list.  Here is a phone-scoped photo of the bird as it slept.


After about 10 minutes I still had no view of the third bird’s head and bill to make a definitive ID.  I started to try to compare sizes since Trumpeters are often a bit bigger than Mutes, but the birds weren’t very close together so comparisons weren’t easy.  Then I realized that the necks of the two Mutes were a bit yellower than that of the sleeping bird – but was that definitive?  Then finally the sleeping bird awoke and raised its head just barely enough to give me a view of the base of the bill – it was all black eliminating Mute Swan.  It also eliminated Tundra, though no Tundras had been reported at the site.  I had my bird – after 15 years Trumpeter Swan was “sanitized for your protection” on my MA list. 

Back in 2004, I counted Trumpeter Swan as #365 on my MA list.  Instead I should have added it in 2019 as #414.  That is assuming MARC ends up accepting this bird in Milford. 

My statebird map for Trumpeter Swan is inserted below.  The shaded states are those where I've seen this species; cross-hatched states are those in which this species is regular but I don't yet have it for that state list.  Most of my sightings in the Midwest and East have been after the Great Lakes re-introduction efforts.  I know my VT sighting in 2017 was countable and accepted by the VT Bird Records Committee.  Hopefully all the others are countable as well, or I’ll have to “sanitize” a bunch of those lists too.