Sunday, July 22, 2018

First Trip to Newfoundland – June/July 2018 - 141 Species – Part 1 of 3


Each year I take an extended birding trip in Spring or Summer to work on my state or province lists.  This year I planned my first ever trip to Newfoundland, with a short side-trip to the French islands of St. Pierre et Miquelon.  As with all my trips, I spent many hours to plan for the best itinerary to maximize my species total.  Unfortunately there aren’t any recent birding guides to Newfoundland, though a somewhat dated “A Bird-Finding Guide to Canada” by J.C. Finlay had a chapter on birding in the province which was helpful at least in a general way.  And then of course there were lots of eBird data to pore over, plus a Newfoundland listserve to watch.  But by far the best information came when I reached out to local birders Alvan Buckley and Jared Clarke.  They provided a lot of general information, as well as tips to bird a number of my key sites.  Many thanks Alvan and Jared!
As I was putting my plans together I made two key observations that were somewhat surprising -
  • Many of the birds that are regular here in New England, and even some that breed north of New England, don't typically make it as far north as Newfoundland.  For instance my common yard birds like Chipping Sparrow, White-breasted Nuthatch, Scarlet Tanager, Eastern Pewee, and Red-eyed Vireo, are not seen at all, or just as rarities, in the province.  And even birds I think of as northern species like Bay-breasted and Blackburnian Warblers are rarities in Newfoundland. 
  • There are few species in general in the area.  A "Big Day", or even just a full day of birding in New England, will often far exceed 100 species.  By comparison, breaking 100 in Newfoundland in a day is quite unlikely.   
The next key observation was that I could need to cover a large area to maximize my Newfoundland list.  If I was going to see those “southern” rarities I would need to head to the southwestern corner of Newfoundland.  And the best part of Newfoundland for seabirds was the Avalon Peninsula which is the easternmost portion of the province.  That meant two of the most important areas to bird were a good 10-hour drive apart.  When I realized the amount of driving I would have to do, I added an extra day to my itinerary.
Armed with all this information, and after several months of preparations, I planned an 8-day itinerary in Newfoundland.  And despite all this birding, I expected perhaps just 96 species in Newfoundland.
Then there is St. Pierre et Miquelon.  The good news is that the schedule for the ferry from Fortune would allow me 2 ½ days on the islands, including a short side trip to the island of Langlade.  The bad news is that there is precious little information about birding there, few eBird posts (none recently), and I was unable to connect with any birders there even to just suggest the best locations to bird while on the island.  Undaunted, I guessed I might get 50 species there, just wandering around St. Pierre on my own looking for nice habitat.  I have to admit I wasn’t exactly expecting the best birding there, but it would likely be my only ever opportunity to get any “ticks” in this tiny ABA jurisdiction.
So I was finally ready for my 11-day trip to Newfoundland and St. Pierre!
This is the first of 3 parts summarizing my trip.  See my next 2 blog posts for the rest of my trip.
Day 1 - June 21 – Fly to St. John’s – Drive to Central Newfoundland
I didn’t arrive into the St. John’s airport until 4 PM local time, so that didn’t give me any real time for birding.  Instead the plan was to head west as far as Bishop’s Falls as I made my way to bird Gros Morne National Park the next day.
Before my trip I started to guess what my first bird might be for Newfoundland.  (In New Brunswick it was most fittingly a Canada Goose!).  Here given the coastal and suburban setting of the airport I guessed it might be a Ring-billed Gull.  Actually it turned out to be a Herring Gull – pretty close.  I had 8 species in route – including a flyover Bald Eagle – a species I didn’t see again until a week later.  It was dusk as I arrived at my hotel room, and I poked my head outside just long enough to hear Junco, Wilson’s Warbler, and Snipe just to wet my appetite.  A rainbow over my hotel was a nice site as well.

Day 2 - June 22 –  Partly Cloudy, low in the mid 40’s, high in the upper 60’s
My original plan was to make an early morning stop at Corduroy Brook Nature Trails in Grand Falls-Windsor, with Summer 2017 eBird posts including Ovenbirds and Red-eyed Vireos which could difficult to find elsewhere during my trip.  But there had been no recent eBird reports from this site so I wondered if this spot could be the best for an early morning walk.  And then just before my trip an eBird post came along from nearby at Jumper’s Brook Resource Road in Bishop’s Fall with Philadelphia and Red-eyed Vireos, so I decided to change my plans to hit this location instead.  And it turned out to be a good choice.  I slowly traveled up this road, making numerous stops along with way in nice varied woodland habitat.   Key highlights among the 30 species I had here in 2 hours and 15 minutes were 2 Philly Vireos, a Red-eyed Vireo, and an Ovenbird – all the key targets I was hoping for at Corduroy and then some.  Plus I heard a Ruffed Grouse – I do a lot of birding by ear and can hear the higher pitched calls really well.  However, the low tones of a Ruffed Grouse are really difficult for me to hear, so I was glad to get this one out of the way.  Also of note were 4 Tennessee Warblers which turned out to be my only ones for the trip.
I also realized that with the smaller number of species in the area, it would be easy to keep an exact count of all species seen/heard – I did that for all my stops in Newfoundland, entering eBird lists of exact counts of the birds I saw or heard.  At Jumper’s Brook this included 15 Yellow-bellied Flycatchers!  And among the 11 warblers I had here, I had 12 Yellows, 10 Black-and-whites, 10 Northern Waterthrushes, 8 Redstarts, 8 Mournings, and 8 BT Greens – most of which were flagged as high totals in eBird.
Next I was off to Gros Morne National Park, but in route to Gros Morne I made a short stop at the Deer Lake sewage impoundments.  Multiple eBird reports from this spot included Shovelers as a rarity, plus quite a diversity of other ducks.  Even though I was standing outside the perimeter fence to the impoundments, I quickly found 3 Shovelers, and regular Ring-necks, Blacks, and Wigeon, plus one Pintail, but missed several others recently reported like Mallard and Green-winged Teal.  Since it only took a few minutes to bird the impoundments, I decided to walk the trail down below the impoundments to see what might be in the marsh below.  Along the way I passed 2 small swampy areas, one of which contained 3 Wood Ducks as a rarity.  Down at the marsh I spotted an American Bittern, and my first Swamp Sparrow singing from the vegetation.  All in all a very nice (and efficient!) stop.
Since it was now midday, my plan was to make multiple stops along the coast in Gros Morne to look for seabirds, and then end the day with a walk through landbird habitat.  Along the way, I took these nice scenery shots at an overlook.


My first stop was Green Point, which had a nice collection of terns - 4 Caspians, and 40 Commons.  I thought Caspians would be tough on the trip, but I ended up seeing them in multiple locations over the next several days.
The next stop was the small community of Sally’s Cove where a flock of gulls included my only Iceland Gull of the trip, and in fact my only rare gull of the trip.  The next quick stop was at Broom Point where I had my first Common Eiders, including a crèche of 11 young with 3 hens.  Surprisingly I only had Eiders at a few locations throughout my trip; they are a common summer nester along much of the New England rocky coast.  I also had my first Arctic Tern of the trip here.  Then I was off to the town of St. Paul’s, but first a quick stop at the marsh just outside town yielded my first of only a few Canada Geese that I would have on the trip– again a bit of a surprise.  My next stop was in town to scan the inlet, and was surprised to find a breeding plumage Razorbill.  In St. Paul’s Bay I spotted a group of 8 Goldeneyes in the distance – only ones of the trip.  And in town there was a flock of 7 Common Grackles, which eBird called a rarity.
It was now late afternoon and time to turn back to landbirding, specifically on the Western Brook Trail.  The first part of this trail went through nice boggy wetlands with numerous Yellowthroats, Swamp and Savannah Sparrows, and Yellow Warblers.  Then I reached patches of woodlands, featuring my only Cape May Warbler of the trip.  And later I found an Olive-sided Flycatcher which was an eBird rarity – surprising that this species was a write-in since I had 7 of them at 5 locations on the trip.  Same goes with Winter Wren – nice singing bird, but a write-in in most places though I had 7 of them during my trek.  Plus I had my first Boreal Chickadee – I love this species.  White-throated Sparrow was most common species with 12, followed by 11 Yellow Warblers.  And a final note of interest - in the woodlands I tried to attract woodpeckers by tapping sticks together as I walked.  Although I never attracted any woodpeckers, I did attract Black-and-white Warblers several times.  I guess a tapping woodpecker could signal a potential source of food for a Black-and-white which similarly gleans insects from tree bark.
Here a couple nice scenery shots from the end of the Western Brook trail.


My last stop of the day was in Rocky Harbour where bird feeders in town were well-known for attracting some nice birds, including difficult-to-find Mourning Doves.  As I pulled up to the area there was a MoDo perched right above me on the wires.  I decided to get out to give it a closer look and quickly heard a bird giving a 3-part buzzy trill – each trill was the same length and same pitch.  A Clay-colored Sparrow, right?  I never saw the bird, but went with my gut of CCSP.  But later in the trip I heard a Junco giving a very similar song with 3 evenly spaces buzzy trills very similar to a CCSP.  Plus I heard 2 other Juncos giving a single long trill that was quite buzzy.  In all my years of birding I don’t think I’ve ever heard Juncos with buzzy trills, not to mention the 3-trill song.  In any case, I ended up calling the Rocky Harbour bird a much more likely Junco instead of a CCSP.
I ended the day with 77 species, and a province list of 78, walking 9.1 miles and 21,700 steps (per my FitBit).  A productive yet tiring day.
Day 3 - June 23 –  AM overcast lows in the low 40’s, PM partly cloudy highs in the mid 70’s
My dawn hike this day was on the James Callaghan Trail leading up to Gros Morne Mountain.  Before I could even start the walk I heard a Philly Vireo calling from the trees surrounding the parking lot.  And as I watched this bird, I spotted 5 Common Mergansers down in the river below.  That was a good start.  The trail had great habitat for Spruce Grouse, and I was the first person on the trail that day, so I was hopeful that I would happen on one.  I spent a lot of time peering into the spruces both on the ground and in the trees for my target grouse, all the while tallying the singing passerines along the way.  Eventually I would end up with one Spruce Grouse well up the trail on my return trip down the mountain.  Another highlight was 3 Pine Grosbeaks – 1 seen and 2 heard singing; this is another of my favorite boreal birds that I don’t see very often.  The species with the most individuals in my 3 hour hike was the ever-present Yellow-bellied Flycatcher at 13; Northern Waterthrush at 7 was the most common warbler.  Here is a picture of the trail, including the very nice spruce habitat, and the valley below way in the distance. 

My next hike was on the Baker’s Brook Falls trail, which thankfully was on more-level ground.  This trail had highly varied habitats including spruce bogs and drier spruce woodlands.  The key addition on this 2 ½ hour hike was a rare singing Nashville Warbler – the only one for the trip.  Other highlights were a family of 6 Gray Jays which were most inquisitive.  And I had 2 more Olive-sided Fly’s and 2 more Winter Wrens (still eBird write-ins).  The “winner” for the most common birds here were 20 Yellow-bellied Flycatchers, 14 White-throated Sparrows, and 11 Black-and-white Warblers.
My original plan was to stay in Gros Morne longer doing more landbirding, but the forecast for the next day was for heavy rain.  So I decided to head out of Gros Morne in the early afternoon to squeeze in a stop at a key landbird spot planned for the next day, the Starlite Trail.  On the way I made another stop at the Deer Lake sewage impoundments.  Interestingly most of yesterday’s ducks were gone – for instance only 2 Ring-necks were there when there were 24 the day before.  But I did add Rock Pigeon to my province list – one of the few times you can get excited about seeing a Rock Pigeon!
Along the way to Starlite I passed a small swampy wetlands and a pair of Rusty Blackbirds flew out – my only ones of the trip.  A lucky observation!
The southwest portion of the island is well-known for “southern” species not often seen in other parts of the province.  Many of these are overshoot migrants, often seen in early June but as I found out, not too likely to stick around.  Others are regular nesters, but only reliably found in this portion of the province.  For instance as I tracked sightings in the weeks leading up to my trip there were reports of quite a number of southern landbird species like Ruby-throated Hummingbird, Least Flycatcher, Eastern Kingbird, Pewee, Catbird, Veery, Parula, Nashville, Bay-breasted and Blackburnian Warblers, Chipping Sparrow, and Bobolink.  And wetlands birds included Great Blue Heron, Pied-billed Grebe, Soras.
Many of these species are seen in an area called the Codroy Valley, with many potential hotspots to visit.  One of the most important is the Starlite Trail where key targets are Least Flycatcher and Veery – this could be their only reliable breeding location in Newfoundland.  Plus this is one of the best spots for Ovenbird.  I arrived at 4:45 PM and was hoping that birdsong would pick up in late afternoon.  But it was still the warmest part of the day – and the black flies were horrendous.  As I made my way up the side of the mountain there were lots of Swainson’s Thrushes singing, so I was hopeful Veery’s would be cooperative as well.  I also heard 2 singing Ovenbirds.  But there was only 1 Yellow-bellied Fly – would that mean the Leasts would be quiet as well?
I was in a very nice mature birch forest habitat which was reported to be the right habitat for the Veery’s, so I made a stop at an overlook to listen.  Within in a few seconds I heard a portion of a song in the distance that could have been a Veery but I didn’t focus on it soon enough.  So I listened intently in the direction of the first song and then heard a full song of a Veery.  Success!  Here’s a picture of the valley below from the “Veery overlook” - that's my car in the parking lot far below.

Now I needed to find the Least Flycatchers.  The recent sightings seemed to suggest they could be farther up the mountain but still in birches, so I continued to climb the trail listening for my target bird.  A short distance farther up the mountain I began to hear chipping that sounded like a Least, though still no song.  I climbed a bit further and heard some more chipping coming from multiple birds.  I played a bit of tape and one responded in song.  Though despite hearing 4 calling birds I could get no visuals.  Although I wanted to stay to see the birds, the black flies were eating me alive, so I decided to head down to the car, happy to have gotten both of my targets.
My hotel was in Port aux Basques a short distance away, and I began the drive west down the Trans Canada Highway.  I had only driven a few miles when I was shocked to see a Cuckoo fly low across the road, flying into the brush next at the edge of the road right in front of me.  Though I saw the bird while I was driving and of course without using binoculars, I could clearly see the Cuckoo’s long-tailed shape and size, and only the slightest hint of any reddish hue in the wings making it a really rare Black-billed Cuckoo.  I wasn’t aware that there had actually been a couple other BB Cuckoo sightings in the general area in the prior couple days, all likely overshooting birds of this late migrant species.
I ended the day with 88 species in Newfoundland.  And although I had just 49 species for the day, many were rarities as far as eBird was concerned - of the 40 Newfoundland rarities listed in eBird that day I had 19 of them.  And with 26,200 Steps, and 10.9 miles walked including 2 treks up and down mountain trails, I was happy to reach my hotel and call it a day.
Day 4 - June 24 – Periods of moderate to heavy rain, strong winds, highs in the low 50s
The forecast was for heavy rain starting mid-morning, which just gave me enough time to bird a couple landbirding spots in the early morning.  My first stop at dawn was Red Rocks Rd. where many southern species were reported earlier in the month as overshooting migrants.  But as it turns out, most of those “southern” vagrants were long gone by the time I got to the area.  I walked the length of the road and back in a little over 2 hours finding lots of birds but adding only 2 to my province list.  The best was an Eastern Pewee which I first heard in song, then got a brief visual along the road, then heard it sing again back in the woods.  I actually might have had a second bird at the far end of the road – I only heard it sing once.  I also added 2 Red Crossbills mixed in with a flock of Siskins.  Other highlights were 4 singing Winter Wrens and a Red-eyed Vireo.  The most abundant bird was Siskin with 42 birds (including a flyover flock of 30).  The most common warblers were Yellow at 12 and Waterthrush at 8.
It wasn’t raining yet when I got back to my car so I still had time to do some more landbirding.  I rearranged my schedule to head to Cheeseman Provincial Park where several “overshoot” landbirds had been reported earlier in the month.  Plus a Wood Thrush had been reported singing there the previous 2 days.  Not to mention there were nesting Piping Plovers on the beach so lots to look forward to.
I arrived at the entrance to pay my park fee, and just as I opened my car window I heard a Northern Parula singing – nice!  I ended up with 2 in the park.  I then headed right to the spot where the Wood Thrush had been singing for the last 2 days, but despite several stops there I was not able to re-find it.  I had single Red-breasted Nuthatches in 2 spots – surprisingly my only Red Nuts for the trip.  61 Siskins again were the most abundant bird (due to a flyover flock of 50), with 5 Blackpolls and 5 Yellow-rumps as the most common warblers.
Then I was off to the coast to try for the Piping Plovers – 9 had been reported a couple days earlier so I was feeling pretty good about my chances.  I arrived at the coast at the middle of the beach – do I walk east or west to try for the plovers?  I decided to walk east but didn’t see any Plovers.  So I turned around and walked west and finally spotted 2 adult Piping Plovers ahead of me as I neared the far end of the beach.  Not wanting to bother these endangered species, I didn’t go any further to try to get a count.  It wasn’t raining yet, though it was very windy, so I decided to do a seawatch to see what wind-blown birds might be passing by.  I got to a spot in the dunes protected from the wind a bit, and added a flyby Red-breasted Merganser, and 3 distant Sooty Shearwaters.  A distant flock of 30 Common Eiders was nice too. 
But now it started to rain, so I headed back to my car and then off to Cape Ray to do another seawatch.  Along the way I made a few quick stops in the town of Cape Ray seeing birds that I mostly only found around the towns like Rock Pigeon, Blue Jay, Starling, and Grackle.  Plus in a small wetlands at the edge of town I found 3 rare Red-winged Blackbirds.
Then it was on to Cape Ray for a seawatch.  It was very windy and rainy, so I needed to bird from the car trying to look downwind as best as possible.  There was not much flying by, but I had my first of many Guillemots, and then spotted an adult Jaeger flying by quite closely.  I quickly got the bird in the scope and watched it for at least 30 seconds – it seemed thin-bodied enough to be a Parasitic, and tail shape seemed right as well.
I had planned to spend additional time landbirding in the area but it was raining heavily, so I decided to call it quits early and head north a short distance to the Codroy Valley.  I thought I might take a quick look at a number of my possible stops I had planned for the next day to get a feel for how I might bird there tomorrow.  But along the way the rain slowed to a drizzle, and since tomorrow’s forecast was for more heavy rain, I thought it would be worthwhile to try to hit at least a couple of tomorrow’s spots yet today if it wasn’t raining too hard.
First I headed to Loch Lomond where I could bird from the road and hopefully not get too wet.  I parked at the east end of the lake and quickly spotted another 3 Wood Ducks – I thought these were supposed to be rarities.  A family of Wigeons and another two families of Black Ducks were also swimming through the vegetation.  With no more waterfowl to look at, I turned my attention to the swallows flying low over the lake.  Interestingly almost all were Bank Swallows, and then I spotted a single Barn Swallow – 2 nice additions to my list.  A singing Red-winged Blackbird was an expected bird in this location.
Then I drove to nearby Shoal Pond where so many rarities had been spotted recently including Pied-billed Grebe, Coot, and Sora, plus a number of waterfowl.  This location would likely require a pretty long walk around the perimeter, so I wasn’t planning to bird there in the rain.  But as I got closer the rain got lighter, and was just a light drizzle when I arrived.  So I got my rain suit on, and decided to head to the lake yet this afternoon.
But then as I started walking east along the southern edge of the pond the fog rolled in and I couldn’t see 50 feet.  Plus the wind was a good 15-20 mph, and now with heavy drizzle it meant I was getting pelted with tiny rain droplets.  Not very conducive for looking for birds on the lake.  The best I could do was listen to a distant calling Bittern.  I kept heading east and finally the fog started to lift.  The first bird I saw on the lake was a rare Shoveler, followed by a family of Wigeon.  Now the fog had pretty much lifted, and I could scan most of the lake.  I looked back to the southwest corner and briefly saw a bird on the water, which then disappeared beneath the surface.  My initial thought was it could be a Grebe, and a few seconds later it reappeared – it was indeed a Pied-billed Grebe, last reported at the lake more than 2 weeks earlier.  A bit later I heard it call, and it was answered by a second bird calling toward the east side of the lake.  Nice!  Not a minute later I spotted another bird out on the water and with the scope verified I had the Coot, also last reported a couple weeks ago. 
I was now at the southeast corner of the lake with a nice cattail marsh in front of me.  I started to hear a staccato “kek kek kek” that initially I was unfamiliar with.  Then I realized it was like a slow version of the “grunt” of a Virginia Rail, and without the call tailing off at the end.  I went to my iBird Pro app and softly played through the various calls – what I was hearing was a perfect match for call #7 “Calls Between a Pair”.  The bird continued to call off and on while I was in ear-shot of it over the next 10-15 minutes.
I was now walking north up the eastern side of the pond, and still hadn’t heard Sora, which was getting to be concerning since this was the Shoal Pond rarity that was the most often reported so far this year.  Up ahead I could see a nice marsh in the northeast corner of the lake which seemed like great habitat for a Sora.  And sure enough as I neared this spot a Sora called, followed soon thereafter by another one nearby, and then a third bird called a bit farther south.  I guess I shouldn’t have been worried.  As I was giving myself a high five, I heard a “bink” of a Bobolink.  A few seconds later I spotted a male Bobolink, followed by at least 2 other males and a female.  All were in the somewhat drier portion of the marsh– don’t think I’ve ever seen Bobolinks in a marsh outside of fall migration.  And I can’t forget the Red-winged Blackbirds out in the marsh – expected at this site though still a rarity for the province.
I had seen or heard just about everything I could reasonably expect at Shoal Pond (and then some), so I headed back to my car.  Along the way the Virginia Rail kept calling, and my first Harrier passed by.  A nice ending of the day – my 80th species that day, and my 107th species in the province.  My FitBit said I had logged 26,100 Steps and 10.9 miles – another long but successful day.

Sunday, May 20, 2018

Two Lifebirds and Three Other Statebirds, South Florida, April, 2018


In 2006 and 2008 I added a few vacation days to business trips to south Florida in search of multiple introduced species.  Some were countable lifebirds, like the Spot-breasted Oriole in 2006 and the Common Myna in 2008 which had recently been added to the ABA list.  But others weren’t, like the Purple Swamphen I specifically sought after and found at Pembroke Pines in 2008.  And during that trip I also had a fly-by Egyptian Goose which unfortunately also wasn’t countable.  Then a few years later the ABA added both the Swamphen (though now determined to be the Gray-headed Swamphen) and the Egyptian Goose to the ABA list.  Unfortunately, even though I had seen both species in the wild, I couldn’t count them because that was before these introduced species were determined by the ABA to have sustainable populations. 
So I needed to get back to south Florida to see both the Swamphen and Goose to fill in these new holes in my ABA list.  Unfortunately I haven’t had any business trips to south FL since 2010, so I’ve had no chances to see these very “gettable” species.  Finally an April 2018 family vacation to visit relatives would provide an opportunity to check them off.  So I made sure to set up an itinerary that included a couple days in southeast FL to look for both targets.  Plus of course there are always a few other statebird possibilities to try for.  I targeted two additional possible statebirds – Nelson’s Sparrow likely still hanging around in saltmarshes on the Gulf Coast, and a flock of Yellow-headed Blackbirds coming to a rice silo just west of West Palm Beach.
Our first stop was to visit relatives north of Tampa.  These relatives live in a subdivision with next to no native vegetation.  That is except for their backyard, which includes a small grove of natural live oaks.  In our previous trips there, these trees have always seemed to attract some nice migrants.  So on our second day there I spent much of the afternoon sitting in the yard watching quite a number of migrants come and go – mostly Palm Warblers, Yellow-rumps, and a Black-and-white.  Then I noticed another warbler that I initially thought was a Yellow-rumped but soon realized it didn’t have a yellow rump.  Upon closer inspection I realized it was a rare female Cerulean Warbler.  I continued to watch it off and on for the next 20 minutes.  That was a most unexpected surprise for this species that typically migrates into the US across the western Gulf.  FL is my 23rd state for this declining species (see my statebird map below).

The next day I headed off to nearby Werner-Boyce Salt Springs State Park to try for Nelson’s Sparrow.  I lived in central FL in the late 80’s, and had numerous wintering sparrows which back then were called “Sharp-tailed Sparrows”.  Of course since then this group has been split into 2 species.  Unfortunately I didn’t look close enough to tell whether the many birds I was looking at in the 80’s would become Saltmarsh or Nelson’s Sparrows.  Although I’m sure I saw both of these common wintering species, I decided to only count the Saltmarsh Sparrow on my FL statelist.  So with that somewhat arbitrary gap in my FL list, I researched possible sites for Nelson’s Sparrow.  It was getting late in the season, and there were no recent posts for this species.  But there were April sightings of Nelson’s at this park in 2006 and 2014 - obviously dated but still worth a try.  Besides the salt marsh couldn’t have changed that much over the years, right?
I arrived at dawn at the trailhead for the Black Rail Trail at the state park, and began my walk.  After a short distance through the woodland, the trail emerged into a very nice saltwater marsh – perfect habitat for the Nelson’s, as well as for Saltmarsh and Seaside Sparrows.  I continued walking along the trail, stopping to play a bit of tape here and there (since Nelson’s can be very tape responsive), but to no avail.  Then after about 30 minutes of watching and listening I finally heard a Nelson’s singing out in the marsh.  I tried to track it down, but it turned out to be too wet so it stayed as a heard only bird.  Later I heard 2 other singing birds, but could never get any visuals.  Interestingly I didn’t have Saltmarsh or Seaside Sparrows while on the walk despite the excellent habitat.
My statebird map for Nelson’s Sparrow has lots of gaps.  First of all, I’ve never had any luck finding it on its Midwest breeding grounds (though I’ve seen it nesting in ME).  I've also seen Nelson's as a nester in 3 Canadian provinces - AB, NS, and PEI.  And my story for Nelson’s in its wintering range along the southern Atlantic coast is the same as it was for FL – I’m sure I saw this species in those states years ago, but my notes are insufficient to be able to count both Nelson’s and Saltmarsh in those states.  So like FL, I’ve only checked off Saltmarsh Sparrow in the states along the southern Atlantic coastline.


As a side note – while along the Gulf Coast I made sure to look at the wintering Willets to be sure I saw a “Western” Willet in hopes that some day this species will be split into two like the “Sharp-tailed Sparrows” were.
Next we were off to southeast FL, and with only a slight diversion we made a stop at the Sem-Chi Rice Mill where 50 or more Yellow-headed Blackbirds had been found feeding with other blackbirds on rice that had been spilled at the mill.  Soon after we arrived I noticed a flock of blackbirds feeding on the ground right next to one of the buildings.  After a short walk I was a safe distance away, and could see many Red-wings, a couple Cowbirds, and 1 or 2 Common and Boat-tailed Grackles, but no Yellow-headeds.  Then I thought I saw a flash of yellow among the flock of blackbirds.  And then as the birds moved around a bit I caught another glimpse of yellow, and eventually spotted an adult male Yellow-headed feeding in the middle of the flock.  The bird didn’t seem too healthy, but it was alive and countable.  I thought about looking for other Yellow-headeds nearby, but since my family was in the car waiting for me, I figured a shorter stop was the better approach.  FL is my 3rd state for this normally western species as a rarity (in addition to MA and NH).


So although it certainly was nice to add 3 birds to my FL statelist, the key targets were still ahead of me – Gray-headed Swamphen and Egyptian Goose as lifers.  With a bunch of eBird research, I found several seemingly reliable locations for the Swamphen not too far from our hotel, but numbers in each case were pretty low.  So I mapped out several possible locations in case I had problems finding my target among the more numerous Common and Purple Gallinules.  My first choice was Green Cay Nature Center and Wetlands southwest of West Palm with recent reports having up to 5 Swamphens along with dozens of Gallinules.
I arrived at Green Cay at dawn, and started to walk slowly along the boardwalk which meanders around the wetlands.  Shortly after I arrived I ran into this Anhinga on the railing as if it were welcoming me to the park.


The first area I came to was full of waders, but I only found 1 Common Gallinule.  There wasn’t much marsh habitat there, so I wasn’t too worried yet.  Then a short distance farther along I finally came into some nice marsh habitat that looked suitable for my target.  And sure enough with a quick scope scan I spotted a Swamphen in the distance.  And as I was about to set up for a distant phone-scoped photo, I heard an odd call coming from the marsh right behind me.  I turned and found a much closer Swamphen giving a call which sounded a bit like a Red-headed Woodpecker.  This most cooperative bird provided this nice Kodak moment.


With the pressure off, I continued to walk along the boardwalk at a leisurely pace and found 3 other Swamphens giving me 5 for Green Cay.  And although the Swamphens were outnumbered by the 30 Common and 3 Purple Gallinules, they really stood out.  The park was full of waders and other marsh birds as well, with one of the highlights being a nice visual of a Least Bittern.
Next I was off to search for my next target – the Egyptian Goose.  Research on eBird suggested there was a pair in most every park or golf course in the area that included a freshwater pond.  But most locations had just a few sightings, and never more than a couple birds.  But as I continued to watch the eBird reports I noticed multiple sightings at the Snook Island Natural Area.  Sightings indicated it was a family group with multiple goslings, so this seemed to be my best opportunity.  But like the Swamphen, I came up with a list of other nearby spots just in case I struck out at Snook Island.
After a short drive from Green Cay I arrived at Snook Island and soon realized that the park was actually a coastal reserve including some nice mangroves (and lots of no-see-ums), but had no freshwater.  Not the proper habitat for the Geese.  But it was adjacent to a golf course with several ponds, so that must be the correct location.  I could see a good portion of the golf course from the fenceline along its southern edge, and I first scanned the closest pond but just came up with a few Mottled Ducks.  Farther out in the park I noticed a couple more waterfowl walking in the grass but they were just Muscovy Ducks (countable but I already had them on my FL list).  Then in the far distance I spotted another bird walking in the grass and got the briefest look of an Egyptian Goose just before it walked over a rise and out of view.  That was enough to add it to my list, but it was a miserable view.  So I decided to drive into the golf course to ask permission to walk around the course a bit and try to get a better view.
A couple minutes later I got to the golf course office but couldn’t find anyone to ask permission.  So I decided to just head off on my own, and the first pond I came to had these 2 Egyptian Geese preening right in front of me. 


I had allotted the whole day to look for my 2 lifers, but had them both before mid-morning.  Do I stay out and do more birding, or head back early to join the family on the beach at the hotel?  As a compromise, I decided to make one brief attempt for another possible target– a Tropical Mockingbird.  This bird first appeared at the Lake Worth Beach parking lot in June 2017, stayed into July, and ended up breeding with a Northern Mockingbird.  From notes in eBird it looked like the locals didn’t think it would be countable, though I don’t think the FL rare bird committee has voted on it yet.  Presumably the same bird was re-spotted a couple weeks earlier, and since the parking lot was only a couple miles away, I decided to give it a try.
I first headed to the southern end of the parking lot where the Mockingbird was typically seen last summer.  With a quick scan the only birds I could find were a pair of Collared Doves.  I walked to the middle of the lot and soon spotted a bird on the wires – it was a Mockingbird but which species?  It took a while for the bird to cooperate, but I was eventually able to ID it as the Tropical – no white wing patches, and a wide white patches in the tip of the tail as shown in this photo.

 
Later it was joined by a Northern Mockingbird and the two appeared to be a pair, spending some time checking out suitable nesting sites. 
This is the second Tropical Mockingbird I’ve seen in the US – the first was one on the TX Gulf Coast which later was determined to be an escaped bird.  Unfortunately birders are likely to reach the same conclusion on this one, even though they nest not too far away on the Yucatan peninsula and in the northern Caribbean.
A most successful trip!  With 2 new lifebirds that brings my ABA Continental Area (not counting Hawaii) total to 754, and my Lower 48 list to 734.  And my FL statelist is now at 319 – conservatively not counting the Tropical Mockingbird, at least for now. 

Saturday, April 14, 2018

Broad-billed Hummingbird, San Francisco, CA, March 2018


My March business trip to the San Francisco Bay Area was around the corner, and I was looking forward to trying to do some early morning or late evening birding while in the area.  But as the trip neared my schedule got busier and busier, and most of my free time, even before or after the 9-to-5 hours, turned out to be limited.  I checked out eBird Needs Alerts anyway, and luckily there was 1 that I might be able to squeeze in.  And it was a really nice rarity at that - a Broad-billed Hummingbird in San Francisco.  This was a first county record, coming to a backyard feeder in downtown San Francisco.  The bird had been there for a while, and was seen daily.  But one recent post mentioned that Broad-bills in CA normally leave their wintering locations by mid-March, so that birder suggested anyone who hadn’t seen it yet shouldn’t wait too much longer.  So I planned to give it a try the first morning I was in the area, though time would be really tight so I could only wait maybe an hour for the Hummingbird to visit the feeder. 

The next morning it was a bit of a daunting task to maneuver around the San Francisco streets in the pre-dawn darkness, but I was able to find the correct neighborhood, and even find a place to park near the location of the feeder.  Directions on a few posts said to stand on 36th Street, and look to the 3rd fenced-in backyard to the east on Geary Boulevard.  I arrived at the viewing spot on 36th Street about 20 minutes before dawn, and in the dim light I looked to the east and could see the small back yards of the Geary Blvd. houses.  Several birders included photos in their eBird reports that showed the feeder attached to a tall tree in that 3rd yard, but others mentioned it was tough to even see the feeder.  So although it was still too dark to hope to see the Hummingbird, I figured I would use this time to locate the feeder and settle in to hopefully wait for the bird to appear.   

With a little searching in the dim light I found the right yard, then the tree that looked like the one shown in the photos.  And then just a couple seconds later I located the feeder.  And then to my surprise I thought I could see a Hummingbird on the feeder.  I looked closer and sure enough it was a Hummingbird, but which species was it?  Earlier lists had included Anna’s, Allen’s, and Rufous at the feeder, so I needed to try to make an ID in the limited light.  With a little concentration I could see that the bird was bluish-green below, and had a reddish base to its bill.  It was indeed the Broad-billed Hummingbird.  I continued to watch it as it fed, and then a minute later it flew off.  Boy was I lucky! 

Here is a photo of the small back yards and the location of the feeder.  Needless to say the Hummingbird is not visible.


I thought about staying to wait for the bird to return and get better views in brighter light after sunrise, but work was calling, and I decided to call it quits and head into the office.  My success made my commute through San Francisco rush hour traffic bearable – well almost.  If only all my searches were as successful as this one.  Earlier in the week my travels took me to Seattle where a brief early morning search for a flock of Common Redpolls was unsuccessful – my visit happened to be on the first day these birds were not seen after 2 weeks of daily observations. 

Broad-billed Hummingbird was statebird #391 for me in CA.  And I was surprised to see that CA was my 7th state for this species – of course in AZ where it is regular, and now 6 other states as a rarity (see my statebird map below).


Thursday, April 5, 2018

Three Statebirds on Galveston Island, TX – March 2018


On my regular March business trip to Houston I ended up with an early morning free, so of course I researched potential statebird possibilities nearby the eBird Needs Alerts.  There weren’t any targets in the greater Houston area, but there were several in and around Galveston Island.  That’s only an hour ride from Houston, so with a pre-dawn departure from my hotel, I could spend a few hours on the coast for some strategic chases.  Recent reports included sightings of a Glaucous Gull, Gannets, an Iceland Gull, and a Black Scoter, though I’d be happy with just 1 or 2. 

The first target was a first year Glaucous Gull with 2 reports of likely the same bird - once from 7 ½ Mile Beach and once from nearby 8 Mile Beach.  I arrived at the area just after dawn, and decided to try 7 ½ Mile Beach first.  As I drove off the pavement and onto the hard packed sand, I could see a group of just 4 gulls on the beach up ahead.  Certainly not enough critical mass for my target bird, right?  But before I had even put the car into park, I realized that one of the gulls was large and very pale.  And with a quick binoc view I realized it was my first year Glaucous Gull.  That was easy!  I got this passable phonescoped photo of the bird as it fed on a fish carcass.


TX is my 21st state for this species (see my statebird map below) – and this is by far the farthest south of all of my sightings.


I looked up and down 7 ½ Mile Beach and didn’t see much activity in the immediate area.  But off to the southwest in the general vicinity of 8 Mile Beach I could see a good sized flock of roosting gulls, so I decided to head in that direction to see if I could find another rare gull.  After a short drive I was there to check out the gulls – just the normal Laughers, Ring-bills, and a couple Herrings.  So with nothing of interest on the beach, I starting scanning out over ocean, hoping I might find a Gannet.  There was one recent report of a nice number of Gannets from “Galveston Island” (no specific location was given), so this location was as good as any to give it a try.  A quick initial scan just yielded the regular species.  But then I spotted a pair of birds flying far out to sea that could be Sulids – but at that distance I couldn’t be sure.  I kept watching them and they were now flying toward me.  Finally, after a minute or so they were close enough to ID as Gannets.  Within the next few minutes I spotted 3 others not too far out, plus 2 others much farther in the distance plunge diving.  That was much easier than I expected – after all I’ve looked for Gannet off the TX gulf coast many times in the past.  Now that I can shade in TX on my statebird map, LA and MS are the last 2 states on the Atlantic or Gulf in which I still need this species.


I was just about to leave 8 Mile Beach when I noticed a large pale gull fly by – it was the first year Glaucous Gull.  Amazing to see it at both locations!  (or at least I assume it was the same bird) 

Since I had such rapid success on my first two targets, I had a bit of extra time on my hands.  So I decided to head into nearby Galveston Island State Park for a bit of light birding, and I chose the Clapper Rail loop for a quick stroll around the marshes.  After a short walk I stopped at the observation tower to listen to what might be calling.  Within a couple minutes I started to hear some clicking noises coming from the marsh.  I listened intently as the bird continued to call – it was a Yellow Rail.  And then while I was celebrating my find, a Black Rail called from the same general area.  I had Black Rail in this same area in April 2017, but Yellow Rail was new for my statelist.  TX was only my 4th state for this elusive species - in MN as a breeder, LA and AR in fall migration, and now TX as a late winterer.


It was a bit interesting that I had Yellow and Black Rail but no Clapper Rail on my walk around Clapper Rail loop. 

Next I was off to the Bolivar Peninsula to chase after a couple statebird possibilities - an Iceland Gull near the Bolivar Flats, and a Black Scoter offshore with Scaup flocks.  I headed right to the beach and soon spotted several flocks of Scaup offshore.  But the rough seas, and distance to the flocks, made viewing difficult, and I once again couldn’t pick out a Scoter (I had tried looking for Scoters in these Scaup flocks last April).  As I continued driving down the beach I checked out the gulls along the way but there were no Icelands.  I was striking out on my targets…  I soon reached the Bolivar Flats and decided to head out on the mudflats to see what I might find.  The Flats were full of shorebirds, and I counted 16 species in total.  There were no rarities, though it was nice to find 6 species of Plovers – Black-bellied, Piping, Snowy, Wilson’s, Semipalmated, and Killdeer.  That included one Piping that was banded, and after some research I found out that the bird was banded on the Missouri River in North Dakota.  Nice!  And then there was this Reddish Egret that had some white feathers in the wingtips – could it be an intergrade between the dark and white forms?


That made for a nice ending to an early morning of birding, finding 2 of my 4 possible stakeout statebirds, plus finding a 3rd statebird on my own.  That gives me 445 on my TX statelist, which is by far my largest single state list.  Though as a percentage of the total birds ever recorded in the state, it is only my 8th best.  My TX list is 71% of the total recorded in the state, whereas my 364 in NH is 91% of the total state list.  If I had 91% of the total TX list my statelist would be a whopping 576.

Saturday, March 24, 2018

Blue Bunting (Lifebird) and Allen’s Hummingbird, Lower Rio Grande Valley, Texas, February 2018


My first ever trip to the Lower Rio Grande Valley (LRGV) in TX was in April 1985.  Back then you could camp inside Bentsen State Park, and many campers would set up makeshift birdfeeders right at their tent sites.  In addition to all the regular south TX specialties I needed on that trip, I was targeting a Blue Bunting that was a regular visitor at a feeder at one of these campsites, including the day I arrived at the park.  I didn’t get to the park until nearly dark, but was able to get the camp site right next to the one with the feeder hosting the Blue Bunting.  I woke up at dawn the next morning fully expecting to add the Blue Bunting to my lifelist at my neighbor’s feeder.  Unfortunately the bird was a no-show, never to be seen again at that feeder.  I wasn’t too disappointed at the time because I would later add 15 other life birds at Bentsen, as part of a trip with 21 lifers.  

Little did I know that Blue Bunting would become a nemesis bird for me.  Despite 13 trips to the LRGV over the years, I would never catch up to a Blue Bunting.  That included a trip in January 2005 when one was found the last day of my LRGV trip but the details of what would become a reliable bird weren’t well-known till after I had left.  Then there was one that I tried for in 2012, though that one wasn’t reliable. 

But by far my worst Blue Bunting miss was of a bird seen regularly from January through April 2016 at Frontera Audubon in Weslaco.  On February 3rd that year I spent 10 hours searching unsuccessfully for that bird, even though it was seen in the park twice that day.  Including one time when I missed it by less than a minute when it was found just 50 feet from me!  Despite finding literally every other rarity that had been recently reported in the park (Crimson-Collared Grosbeak, Tropical Paula, Painted Bunting, Summer Tanager, Ovenbird, etc.), I wasn’t lucky enough to be in the right place at the right time to see the Blue Bunting.  Just goes to show you that despite one’s skill level, or how much upfront detective work you complete, luck is often still needed to find your target species.   

Like I said – a nemesis bird! 

Then in late December 2017 a Blue Bunting was found at the Quinta Mazatlan park in McAllen.  The bird continued to be reported almost daily into early 2018, so of course it was on my radar screen.  So when my regular work trip to Houston came up in January, I thought about adding a day to the Valley to give it a try.  But work and home constraints prevented me from making the trip.  And besides, my unsuccessful search just 2 years earlier dampened my enthusiasm about setting up yet another trip to the LRGV to try for another Blue Bunting.   

But the daily reports kept rolling in – it was like they were taunting me.  After all, my February Houston trip was only a few weeks away.  So when the reports continued, I decided to head to the LRGV once again, setting up my itinerary to devote the entire day on a Monday if needed to try for the Bunting.  As the trip neared I traded e-mails with one local birder who posted about his sighting on the TX listserve - and I’m sure glad I did.  It turns out that he mentioned that Quinta Mazatlan was closed on Sundays and Mondays.  That meant I had just set up my flights to spend an entire day looking for my target bird on a day when the park would have been inaccessible!  Amazing that this very important tidbit had not been mentioned on NARBA, the TX listserve, or any eBird reports.  But now that I knew about the park hours, I looked back at past sightings and sure enough there were no reports on Sundays and Mondays.  So I quickly changed my flights to spend a Tuesday at the park instead of Monday.  Maybe my luck was changing…  My 13th trip to the LRGV, and my 4th try for a Blue Bunting, was on! 

I arrived at the park at dawn that morning and quickly made my way to a spot called the Amphitheatre where the Blue Bunting was most often reported.  This was a large feeding station with multiple rows of stone “seats” arranged like an amphitheatre giving you a nice view of the feeders.  Interesting that there were seats for more than 50 people – surely you would never have that many people watching the feeders, right?  I was the first to arrive, and positioned myself on the right side of the seats to give me the best view of the feeders that the Bunting preferred to visit.  Not surprisingly the feeders were all empty since they had last been filled 2 days earlier on Saturday, the last time the park was open.  But there were some spilled seeds on the ground, so I just sat back and waited for birds to come in. 

But there were no birds.  In my first hour I didn’t have a single bird come into the feeding station.  A couple more birders arrived, and by 8:30 we hadn’t seen any birds.  Though at about 8 AM I did hear several sharp chips notes coming from the underbrush nearby.  Over the years searching for Blue Buntings I remember that several local birders suggested the best way to find this species is to learn its call note since they are quite vocal.  So although none of the reports of this bird mentioned it was calling, I still studied the call note anyway.  And the calls I heard early that morning sounded a lot like the call note of a Blue Bunting.  But it only called for a few seconds, and I never saw any movement, so I didn’t think too much of it. 

At 8:30 a park employee arrived and filled all the feeders, so I was hopeful things would pick up.  As did the other birders – which now numbered 20 or so.  And then a few minutes later a large group of 25 or more birders showed up, or maybe I should call them “so-called birders”.  Even if everyone is on their best behavior, it’s tough for a group of 50 people to be quiet.  And unfortunately this last group of birders wasn’t exactly on their best behavior – there was a lot of talking, people taking phone calls, moving around, etc.  I overheard one person mention they had a Noon flight that day, so I anxiously waited for this noisy crowd to leave so that hopefully birds would come into the feeder.  Over the next 90 minutes there were visits by just 2 Green Jays, 2 Kiskadees, 3 White-tipped Doves, and 1 banded Orange-crowned Warbler – amazingly that was it, at a well-stocked feeding station in south TX!  One of these loud birders mentioned that this was their second unsuccessful try for the Blue Bunting in the last week – I’m not surprised given their behavior. 

Finally at 10 AM the loud birders left, and the 20 birders that remained were now much quieter – finally a group that was truly focused on seeing the target bird.  And not 10 minutes later I heard sharp chip notes coming from the underbrush at the edge of the feeding station.  They were similar to the Orange-crowned Warbler chips of the bird that had come in earlier, but a bit sharper.  I stared into the underbrush and noticed some movement.  Within a couple seconds I saw the bright blue of the Blue Bunting.  It was skulking way back in the brush, but I was able to get most of the other birders on it.  Over the next 10 minutes the bird continued to call, but was only visible a few times.  And twice we actually saw it fly through the brush, and with fleeting glimpses it appeared all black.  All things considered, these were very nice sightings after a nearly 3 hour wait.  My 4th time was the charm.  And it was likely more than coincidental that the bird appeared only minutes after the loud birders left.   

I wasn’t able to get any pictures of the bird, but I took this picture of the feeding station, with an arrow toward the brush on the left where the Blue Bunting had been skulking earlier.


And this is a shot of the seating area of the amphitheatre, with the “small” group of 22 well-behaved birders.
 

My looks at the bird weren’t the best, and I thought about staying longer to try to get a better view.  But frankly I was tired of birding in a big noisy crowd.  So with the rest of the day available for birding, I headed out of the park to pursue other TX statebird possibilities.  (Of course I had done my research to see what other statebirds might be around.) 

The first statebird possibility was an Allen’s Hummingbird that had been coming to a feeder in Harlingen.  I contacted the homeowner, Justin LeClair, to get his permission to come into his yard to look for his bird.  It turns out Justin formerly lived in New England and he remembered me.  He gave me some great tips to look for the Allen’s, including that it was mostly coming to the feeder in front of the house, and that it might roost on a citrus tree next door when not at the feeder.  He also had Rufous, Black-chinned, Ruby-throated, and Buff-bellied Hummingbirds coming to his feeders, so it sounded like it could be fun to spend some time at his feeding station. 

After a short drive I arrived at Justin’s house, and quickly found the feeder out front and the ones in the backyard.  And I found the citrus trees next door.  But I didn’t find any Hummingbirds.  But not to worry – I just positioned myself where I had a good view of the front feeder and waited.  Within a couple minutes a Selasphorus Hummer arrived.  It fed from the far side of the feeder which meant it was facing me.  Not the best angle to see its back color, but brief glimpses suggested it had an orange back to I figured it was a Rufous.  Then a short while later a female Archilochus Hummer arrived.  It too fed on the far side of the feeder facing me.  Hmm…  Would all the Hummingbirds just feed on that far side of the feeder?  Assuming that was going to be the case, I repositioned myself so that I was on the other side of the feeder, and the Hummers’ backs would then be towards me.  The next visit was of another or the same female Archilochus, again landing on that same perch, and this time giving me a great view of the back of the bird.  So hopefully now I was in the right position to see the back color of any future Selasphorus that came to the feeder, and make an accurate ID. 

I waited a bit longer and heard sharp chip notes of a Hummingbird coming from somewhere in the front yard.  Seconds later a Selasphorus arrived at the feeder, again landing on the perch giving me a good look at the back of the bird.  It was nearly solid green – it was the Allen’s Hummingbird.  Over the next several minutes there were several other visits by Hummingbirds, interestingly all landing on that same side of the feeder.  Good thing I had a good view of that portion of the feeder.  And many thanks to Justin for inviting me to his feeding station!  TX was my 3rd state for Allen’s Hummingbird, joining CA and MA as a rarity.  Plus I now have 13 species of hummingbirds on my TX list – more than any other state. 

Next I was off to the Brownsville Dump.  Although this spot is known as THE spot for Tamaulipas Crows in the US, my targets here were actually Gulls – both Glaucous and Iceland (Thayer’s) had been reported here recently.  And since I was heading there I may as well look for the Crows since I had only seen them once before – back in 1985 on that same first visit to the LRGV.  I arrived at the landfill, checked in, and headed right to the active portion of the landfill.  I could see a large flock of Gulls flying around the tractors, plus others perched on the dirt nearby.  Although I positioned myself out of the way of the equipment, I was downwind of all the activity.  And it was really windy.  I sat in my car, rolled down the window, and tried to look for my target Gulls.  But bits of who knows what started to fly into my car.  Yuck!  I lasted only a couple minutes, before I feared for my health and gave up.  I headed back downhill and made a feeble attempt to look for the Crows, but I couldn’t stand it anymore and left the landfill.  Interesting that I remember that my 1985 visit was very similar – that time I was outside my car and the wind would carry paper that would wrap itself around my legs.  I got the Crows on that visit, but I was still grossed out. 

I had no more possible TX statebirds to chase after, so I decided to target species I had only seen once before on previous LRGV trips.  My next stop was at the Inn at Chachalaca Bend where a Rose-throated Becard had been spotted – my only other sighting of this species was on my 2005 trip to the LRGV.  I spent a couple hours wandering around this area, with very nice natural habitat, but came up empty – not only for the Becard but also finding very few birds at all in the excellent woodland and brush.  A similar story to the lack of birds at Quinta Mazatlan. 

It was now pretty late in the day and I decided to make my last stop at an evening roost for Red-crowned Parrots and Green Parakeets.  I had seen both species only once before – the Parrot in 1985 and the Parakeet in 2000, and both in McAllen.  With a bit of eBird research it looked like once again McAllen could be the best area to look for both species, with reports coming from a number of locations.  However, only rarely were both reported in the same spot.  So I ended up picking a hotspot labeled “Red-crowned Parrot Roost” on E. Houston Ave. as the one which would most likely yield results.  I got there about an hour before sunset and started my vigil.  There were a number of Turkey Vultures passing by low to the south, apparently heading to their evening roost.  Included in the group was a Zone-tailed Hawk doing its best Turkey Vulture imitation – nice.  Then I heard distant calls that I thought were coming from a flock of Parrots – but when I spotted them it turned out to be 5 Green Parakeets.  That was an unexpected bonus.   

But I still needed the more likely Parrot.  I kept my eyes and ears open, and continued to see a few Vultures pass by.  The next bird that caught my eye was a very large Accipter with extensive white fluffy undertail coverts.  If I was back home in New England I would have instantly thought it was a Goshawk.  But this was south TX where a Gos would be virtually unheard of.  With closer scrutiny I could see it was an adult that lacked the white eye-line of a Gos, so it must have just been a female Cooper’s.  I’ve never seen a Cooper’s with such extensive white undertail coverts.  And while I was checking the Sibley app to make sure of the ID, I heard more Parrot calls.  This flock was much closer, and I could see this time they were indeed Parrots.  I estimated 35 birds in the flock, and as they landed in a nearby tree I could see they were all Red-crowned Parrots, rather than the couple other less likely (and uncountable) Parrots - Red-lored and Yellow-headed Parrots - that are sometimes seen in the area.  A nice ending to my day, and a nice ending to the trip. 

The Blue Bunting was number 752 for my Continental ABA list (not counting Hawaii), and #731 for my Lower 48 list.  And with 2 additions to my TX list, that brings my statelist to 442.

As a postscript, I put together this little summary of my now 14 trips to the LRGV and nearby locations -
  • April 1985 - 21 lifers, including my only ever Tamaulipas Crows, Brown Jays, and Red-billed Pigeons
  • April-May 2000 - 12 lifers, including my only Ferruginous Pygmy-Owls, Gray-crowned Yellowthroat, White-collared Seedeaters, and Muscovy Ducks
  • January 2005 - 4 lifers, including my only Becard, Green-breasted Mango, and White-throated Robin
  • December 2009 - 1 lifer - Northern Jacana
  • January 2011 - 2 1/2 lifers - Black-vented Oriole, Rufous-Backed Robin, and "Mangrove" Yellow Warbler
  • February 2011 - 1 lifer - Yellow-faced Grassquit
  • January 2012 - 1 lifer - Golden-crowned Warbler
  • November 2013 - 1 lifer - Amazon Kingfisher
  • June 2014 - 1 lifer - Yellow-green Vireo
  • August 2014 - unsuccessful attempt for Collared Plover
  • April 2015 - 1 lifer - Aplomado Falcon
  • August 2015 - 1 lifer - Collared Plover
  • April 2016 - unsuccessful attempt for Blue Bunting
  • February 2018 - 1 lifer - Blue Bunting