Showing posts with label North Carolina. Show all posts
Showing posts with label North Carolina. Show all posts

Saturday, November 7, 2026

LeConte’s Sparrow, Warren Wilson College, Buncombe County, NC, October 25, 2026

Early in the morning on October 24th a post came across the Blue Ridge Birders text group that a Nelson’s Sparrow was found at Warren Wilson College (WWC), complete with an excellent photo.  WWC is well-known in fall for its sparrows in a wet grassy ditch in the middle of their agricultural fields.  It’s a perfect spot for Nelson’s Sparrows and I was lucky enough to hear a singing Nelson’s there back in October 2025.  So, since I didn’t need Nelson’s Sparrow as a state or county bird, I didn’t chase after today’s find.

But then mid-afternoon on the 24th came a text simply saying “LeConte at WWC too?”.  Attached was a “no-doubt” photo of a LeConte’s Sparrow.  That’s one I not only needed for my Buncombe County list but also for my NC state list.  Certainly, one to chase after, but I couldn’t get out that afternoon to give it a try.  Hopefully it would stick around till the next morning.

I arrived at WWC at sunrise on the morning of the 25th and there were already a number of birder’s cars at the designated parking location.  Within a couple minutes I was at the sparrow ditch, and walked up to the birders.  The LeConte’s was just seen a few minutes before my arrival.  So it was still around, though I wished I had gotten there just a few minutes earlier.  The next couple minutes seemed like hours as I peered low into the vegetation hoping to see some movement.  Then someone called that they had re-found it just a few feet away.  I first got some pretty miserable looks as only tiny portions of the bird were visible in the low grasses.  Then finally the bird popped into the open no more than 10 feet away, though still no more than knee-high.  I was standing next to birding friend Aaron Guillotte at the time, and he got these excellent shots of the LeConte’s Sparrow.



We stayed with the LeConte’s for several more minutes, as it acted like a typical LeConte’s.  It would disappear into the low grasses, just a few feet away.  Then we’d notice some movement of the grasses as the bird moved like a mouse through the vegetation.  Eventually the LeConte’s would pop into the open, though typically only briefly before dropping back into the grass to disappear once again.

This experience reminded me of the time I saw a stakeout LeConte’s in Massachusetts in February 2013.  This is from my blog post summarizing that observation:

“A rare LeConte’s Sparrow was found feeding on a cleared shoulder of a small suburban road in Concord, MA.  The bird was reported to be very tame, and was easily found by everyone that posted.  I arrived at the spot and saw 6 birders standing along the roadside – with binoculars and monster lenses apparently trained on the bird.  Amazingly – they were practically looking down at their feet.  I walked up and realized the bird was no more than 5 feet away from me, crawling mouse-like under grasses on the road shoulder that couldn’t have been more than 2 inches high.  After a few seconds I noticed movement in the grasses, and I got amazing views of the head and back of the bird.  What a gorgeous little bird!”

Now back to WWC – After getting multiple views of the Le Conte’s, I mentioned to Aaron that I wanted to try for the Nelson’s.  I didn’t realize that Aaron had discovered that bird the previous day (Congrats Aaron!), and he offered to take me to the spot where he had had it. Within a couple minutes we were back where Aaron had it on the 24th, and found a couple birders pointing into the vegetation.  A few seconds later we had the Nelson’s Sparrow.

I ended up with 9 species of sparrows that morning at WWC – 10 if Towhee counts as a sparrow. 

LeConte’s Sparrow was number 334 for my NC list.  My statebird map for this species is inserted below.  The light blue-shaded states are those where I’ve seen this species in its regular range – as a breeder in the upper Midwest, migrant in Kansas and Oklahoma, and a wintering bird in Texas and Louisiana.  The cross-hatched states are those where I’ve yet to see LeConte’s in its normal range.  Finally, the four dark-blue shaded states are those where I’ve seen LeConte’s Sparrow as a rarity – Wyoming (where I found and photographed the 3rd state record), Maine, Massachusetts, and now North Carolina.



Saturday, October 10, 2026

A Flock (!) of Hudsonian Godwits, Hooper Lane, Mills River, NC, August 21, 2026

On Friday, August 21 I was scheduled to lead a bird walk at the Biltmore.  But rain started overnight and looked to continue well into the morning.  So we cancelled the walk, and I started to think about other places to bird where the rain would actually be beneficial for birding.  Shorebirds, gulls, and terns tend to migrate in rainy conditions, and can even have fallouts in unusual locations.  So I decided to focus on the local hotspots where these waterbirds will often be seen in the rain.

The first location I headed to was Lake Julian in Buncombe County.  While I was on my way to Julian a text came across the local Blue Ridge Birders text group that a Black Tern was spotted there.  Unfortunately, by the time I got to Lake Julian the Tern had departed.  But maybe that boded well for rarities to show up elsewhere.

Next, I was on to the sod farm along Hooper Lane and Butler Bridge Road in Henderson County.  A good collection of shorebirds had been seen recently at Butler Bridge Road so that was my first stop.  But all I found there were the regulars – no new migrants had dropped in with the rain. 

Then I was headed to the south end of the sod farm on Hooper Lane where shorebirds had also been seen in the last week.  But before I could get to the south end I noticed 4 birders together in the distance down the “Birder’s Trail” – the only trail we’re allowed to walk on at the sod farm.  I wondered if they had something of interest.  As I always say – “bird the birders”, so I headed out to the group to see what they might have.  I was well down the trail when another text came across from the text group – “Nora Shipman has found 46 Hudsonian Godwits at Hooper Ln, 2/3 the way down birder trail.”  Wow – simply amazing! 

I picked up my pace and was practically running when I reached the birders.  When I arrived they simply pointed ahead and there was a tightly packed flock of sleeping Hudsonian Godwits.  Most were in basic plumage, though a few had some reddish feathering below remaining from breeding plumage.


After a while they woke up and began milling around a bit and we were able to get an accurate count of 48 birds. They were my 31st shorebird species I've seen at the Hooper Lane sod farm.

I’m glad I got there when I did because the birds didn’t stay long.  Only a couple hours after the Godwits were reported a Red-tailed Hawk flew by and flushed the entire flock.  If the Biltmore walk hadn’t been cancelled, I wouldn’t have been able to see them.

Hudsonian Godwit was #332 for my NC list.  And with the Sabine’s Gull the day before, it’s pretty amazing to be lucky enough to add birds to my NC list on consecutive days. 

My statebird map for Hudsonian Godwit is inserted below.  The light blue-shaded states are those where I’ve seen this species in its regular range – as a spring migrant through the middle of the country, a fall migrant in the east, or a breeder in Alaska.  The cross-hatched states are those where I’ve yet to see it in its regular range.  Finally, the three dark-blue shaded states are those where I’ve seen Hudsonian Godwit as a rarity – Washington, Vermont, and now North Carolina.


 

Wednesday, April 23, 2025

Purple Gallinule, Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, April 16, 2025

On April 14th I noticed several reports on the NC rare bird alert that the Purple Gallinule was “still here” in Mecklenburg County.  It was first discovered by Trevor Kienzle on the 13th – though I missed that post.  The bird was reported again on the 15th so it was apparently pretty reliable.  And the site was only about 2 hours away.  The chase was on!

Now it was time to do more research.  The Gallinule was feeding on aquatic vegetation on the Catawba River at the eBird hotspot called Walker’s Ferry Road Cove.  And one birder posted coordinates of the gravel lot where you should park, the coordinates where the bird was feeding, and the trail you take to get to the spot.  Excellent!  I reached out to Cleveland County birding buddy Bill Hooker to see if he needed the Gallinule for his Mecklenburg County list.  Not surprisingly a rarity like this would be new for his county list, so he was interested in coming along to look for the bird as well.

And there was one other factor that would help us with our chase.  I noticed that Bill’s friend Patty Masten had already seen the bird, so I asked if Bill could connect with Patty for any tips to find our target bird.  Patty offered us even more help – she would meet us at the parking area and take us to where she had the Gallinule.  Our odds of finding the bird just improved dramatically.

I was out of the house early on the 16th, and met Bill in Cleveland County by 7:30.  From there we car-pooled to Mecklenburg County and arrived at the parking area a bit after 8.  Patty was already waiting for us, and we instantly started our short walk down an eastward trail toward the Gallinule spot.  Along the way we met a birder coming back who had just seen the bird.  We picked up the pace a bit and soon reached the spot where Patty had seen our target.  And within seconds we all spotted the Purple Gallinule feeding amongst the vegetation.  Here’s a shot of the bed of vegetation in the distance - the Gallinule is at the blue arrow.

Although the Gallinule was visible the whole time we were there, we never saw much more than the neck and head of the bird.  Luckily the purple feathering and orange bill were conclusive field marks, even in the backlit conditions. 

Purple Gallinule was #328 for my NC state list.  My statebird map for Purple Gallinule is inserted below.  The light blue-shaded states are those where I’ve seen this species in its regular range.  Cross-hatched AR is the last state in its range where I’ve yet to see it. And now NC is the 4th state where I’ve seen it as a rarity (the dark blue-shaded states).



Friday, March 28, 2025

Townsend’s Warbler, Charlotte, North Carolina, March 14, 2025

On the morning of March 7 a text came across the local Blue Ridge Birders text group that a Townsend’s Warbler was coming to a feeder in Charlotte.  Although it was first being reported on the 7th, there was a rumor that it had been present for a couple weeks.  So it certainly seemed to be reliable.  That would be a great bird to chase after and try to add to my NC state list.  It was within my self-imposed 2-hour driving limit to chase rarities – well sort of.  And the homeowner was quite accommodating, allowing birders to watch his feeders from inside his house.

Now it just needed to stick around until I was free.  Unfortunately, I had commitments for each day over the next week and wasn’t free until the 14th.  And even on that day I needed to be home by about Noon.  I kept watching the reports and the Townsend’s Warbler continued to be seen quite regularly at the feeder.  That is until the 13th when it wasn’t seen until the afternoon.  That was more than a bit troubling, but I decided to go for the chase after all, though giving it maybe just a 50/50 chance of success.

After an early 6 AM departure I arrived at the Warbler site just after 8 and the homeowner met me at the door.  He said he hadn’t seen it yet that morning but I was welcome to come inside to watch the feeders.  That sounded inviting, but instead I opted to watch for it in the backyard.  Not only are the feeders visible from the yard, but the bird was also sometimes being seen from the yard both before coming to the feeder and after leaving it. 

The yard was quite birdy, with nearly constant activity at the nice feeding station.  Here is a picture of the backyard deck – the Warbler was coming to the suet feeder toward the left.


The homeowner pointed out the trees in which the Warbler was most often seen, including a nice cedar that looked like one that a Townsend’s might visit in its natural habitat.  So I was all set and ready to wait it out.  At least for a couple hours anyway. 

Just after I arrived a bright yellow Pine Warbler dropped in to eat mealworms – that got my heart racing momentarily but it wasn’t the target bird.  Then no more than 5 minutes later a small bird flew into a deciduous tree overhead.  I got a glimpse of yellow on the bird as it landed, but was it just another Pine?  I got it in my binoculars and it was instead the target Townsend’s Warbler!  It then flew to the feeder where I got these “digi-bin” pictures.


Over the next 90 minutes the bird visited the feeder roughly every 30 minutes, each time pausing in several different trees in the back yard, including the juniper.  And a couple times it even sang softly.  What a great show, especially after its limited visits the day before.

I can’t thank the homeowner enough for his hospitality!

My state bird map for this species is inserted below.  The light blue-shaded states are those where I’ve seen it in its regular range.  The cross-hatched states are those where I’ve yet to see it in that range.  And the 4 dark blue-shaded states are those where I’ve seen Townsend’s Warbler as a rarity – one I found on my own in NH, at feeders in MA, as a woodland stakeout in RI, and now at feeders in NC.  Townsend’s Warbler was #327 for my NC list.  (Interestingly, Townsend's Warbler was #327 for my RI list as well.)



Sunday, January 14, 2024

Harris’s Sparrow, Warren Wilson College, Buncombe County, North Carolina, December 31, 2023

This post came across the local Blue Ridge Birders text group late on December 20th –

       Perfect photo of a Harris’s Sparrow from a checklist today Warren Wilson

I opened the eBird checklist and there it was - a photo of a Harris’s Sparrow at Warren Wilson College, one of my favorite local birding spots.  What a great rarity to chase!  The problem was I was away on a family vacation at the time.  However, I’ve chased quite a number of vagrant Harris’s Sparrows over the years and in most cases birds discovered in winter have remained for an extended period of time.  So I was hopeful this bird would stick around too, at least until the afternoon of the 31st which would be my first opportunity to try for it.

Perhaps the bigger issue was being able to re-find the bird.  The checklist for the initial sighting didn’t provide a specific location, instead just stating the location as “river trail by fields”.  Plus the birder covered a 6-mile-long distance over 3 hours, which was no help as well.  In fact, the River Trail at Warren Wilson is many miles long, and is adjacent to fields in many locations.  But despite what seemed like a long shot, quite a number of birders descended on Warren Wilson the next day, and indeed the bird was re-found and seen by many. 

But the Harris’s location wasn’t pinned down quite yet.  Over the next several days the bird was re-spotted in multiple locations throughout the property, and often associating with different sparrow flocks in those different locations.  As a result, several birders needed multiple visits to find the bird, and others weren’t able to see the bird at all in those initial days.

Then finally on the 30th came the break we all needed.  The local Buncombe County Christmas Bird Count was on that day, and Warren Wilson College was in the count circle.  What a great species to try to add to the CBC tally!  John Koon covered that territory for the count and we were all hopeful he could locate it that day.  And sure enough, John sent out this text that morning –

        Harris’s Sparrow!  In the pigpen past the green pond with a bunch of WCSP and RW blackbirds.  Good looks.

Several others saw the Harris’s there that day.  So maybe this could become the bird’s preferred location.

I had committed to do another CBC on the 31st so couldn’t try for the Harris’s Sparrow until I had completed my territory.  While out counting that morning I checked the reports and the sparrow was once again spotted in the pigpen area of Warren Wilson.  I was cautiously optimistic.

After completing my territory, I drove to the closest public parking spaces to Warren Wilson (at Owen Park), arriving about 12:30.  From there I headed straight to the pigpen area, which even at a brisk pace took 15 minutes or more.  When I arrived, there were 2 birders near the pond – they said they hadn’t found the target bird but there was another birder down the trail also looking.  A minute later I met up with that third birder and he too hadn’t found the bird.  But just then I noticed a lot of movement in one of the pens in the distance – it was a large flock of White-crowns.  Seconds later the other birder said he had the bird.  In a split second I spotted the Harris’s Sparrow feeding on the ground, apparently eating grain spilled from the adjacent feeding trough.  The bird was only in view for about 10 seconds before the whole flock took off into the adjacent brush.  I waited another hour or more for it to return but the sparrow flock seemed to have moved farther down the hedgerow in the distance and did not return.  Here’s a picture of the pig pen area - the Harris’s was in the back of the pen near the blue X.

Good thing I didn’t stop to bird along the walk or I would have missed my target bird.  And I felt a little bad for that other birder.  Apparently it took him 3 days to see the Harris’s Sparrow, yet I was able to see it literally within seconds of arriving. 

Harris’s Sparrow was #325 for my NC state list. 

My statebird map for Harris’s Sparrow is copied in below.  The blue-shaded states are those where I’ve seen this species in its regular range.  The cross-hatched states are those in its normal range where I’ve yet to see it.  And the brown-shaded states are those where I’ve seen Harris’s Sparrow as a rarity.  This species is certainly prone to vagrancy – I’ve now seen it in more states as a vagrant than in its regular range.


Wednesday, January 3, 2024

Broad-tailed Hummingbird, Union County, North Carolina, November 29, 2023

On the afternoon of November 25th a post came across the NC Rare Bird Alert looking for opinions on the ID of a hummingbird described on recent Facebook posts.  The bird was coming to a backyard in Union County, and the homeowner was unsure of the species.  There were multiple comments on the Rare Bird Alert and after a while consensus was pointing towards it being a Broad-tailed Hummingbird – only a second NC state record.  The bird was seen again by the homeowner the morning of the 26th, but by the time access information got out to birders that afternoon, the bird was no longer being seen.

Birders were onsite early the next morning but to no avail.  I was just about to write this one off when a post came across the Rare Bird Alert at 12:21 that afternoon that the hummingbird had just returned.  The bird quickly became a regular visiting both camellias and feeders in the homeowner’s backyard throughout the afternoon of the 27th and all day on the 28th.  So now that the Broad-tailed had become reliable, it was time for a chase. 

I had planned to head out pre-dawn the next morning but it was cold that day, with lows in the mid 20s.  I wondered if the hummingbird made it through the night, and part of me thought that I should wait until it was reported that morning to start to make my drive.  But I was ever the optimist, and decided to head out early anyway.  Hopefully I made the right choice. 

I arrived at Snapdragon Court in Union County at about 9 AM and was the first birder there that day.  Even before I was out of the car the homeowner came out to greet me.  He was happy to share the news that the bird made it through the night and he had seen it several times already that morning.  Looks like I made the right decision after all.

I walked around the side of the house and entered this very nicely landscaped backyard.


I did a quick scan of the feeders and camellias on the deck but didn’t see my target bird.  So I started to scan the nearby deciduous trees and quickly spotted a small bird perched nearby – it was the Broad-tailed Hummingbird.  Just a few seconds later the bird flew into the feeder and gave great views only a few feet away.  Over the next 45 minutes the bird visited the feeding station every few minutes.  The bird appeared to be bigger than a Rufous, with a tail that was longer as well.  All consistent with the Broad-tailed ID, though I’ll leave that up to the wintering hummingbird experts. 

My statebird map for Broad-tailed Hummingbird is inserted below.  The blue-shaded states are those where I’ve seen it in its regular range.  The cross-hatched states are regular states where I’ve yet to see it.  And I’ve seen it in 3 states as a rarity – LA, FL and now NC where it is #324 on my statelist.


Tuesday, October 10, 2023

Limpkin, Mountain Creek Park, Catawba County, NC, August 26, 2023

There had been quite a number of sightings of Limpkins throughout the southeast in the summer of 2023.  This species is not generally prone to vagrancy.  But this year, it was apparent that some type of post-breeding dispersal was occurring similar to what happens with other waders.  Unfortunately, all the reports were quite distant from home, including several in central NC and a couple in central TN. 

But then I noticed a Limpkin report from Catawba County on August 25.  The bird was seen at Mountain Creek Park a bit northwest of Charlotte about a 2-hour drive from home – within my self-imposed driving limit.  I could chase after it the next day, but some of the local Limpkin reports were one-day-wonders.  So it sure would be nice to know that the bird would stick around before I made the trek. 

As it turns out my birding friend Bill Hooker was also interested in pursuing this bird to add it to his Catawba County list.  He was able to relocate it on the 25th, and went back on the morning of the 26th and found it again quite easily.  Bill passed along his suggestions to find the Limpkin – set up your scope on the fishing pier and scan the islands and small mudflats a short distance away.  Although the bird was sometimes seen in the open on the flats, it seemed to prefer perching somewhat obscured in low branches in front of the right most island as you look out from the pier.  With that great advice I was all set and headed off for Mountain Creek Park.

I arrived just after 1 PM in the heat of the day – my car thermometer said the outside temperature was 100 degrees – yikes! 


I quickly made my way to the fishing pier, which thankfully was partially shaded.  I did a quick scan of the island to the right but came up empty.  Then with my scope set up in the shade I searched that right-most island more closely but could not find the Limpkin.  Slow scans of the flats and remaining portions of the islands were unsuccessful as well, with the best find being a Pectoral Sandpiper. 

This was going to be a challenge.  If I was going to be successful, I would need to just settle in and keep doing frequent scans of those islands.  About a half hour after I arrived I heard the unmistakable calls of a Limpkin coming from the shoreline a short distance away.  But the calls were a little too good – it was another birder playing tape. 

Then a half hour later I finally got the break I needed – I noticed a large brown bird flying from the back of the right island towards the flats.  With a quick scope view I had my Limpkin!  I was able to get a couple quick phonescoped shots as it briefly walked out in the open.


A few seconds later it walked into vegetation toward the left and disappeared.  It was in view for maybe just 60 seconds.  I remained there for another hour hoping to get better views but it never re-emerged.  I guess a 1-minute distant view over 2 hours would have to be good enough.

Limpkin was #323 for my NC statelist.  And now NC is my third state, after FL and SC, for this expanding species.

 

As a postscript – just a couple weeks after the Mountain Creek Park sighting a Limpkin appeared at Jackson Park only 15 minutes from home.  I saw this bird on September 9, which certainly was much more cooperative than the one in Catawba County.  I could have saved myself a 2-hour drive if the Jackson Park bird had shown up a couple weeks earlier.


Tuesday, January 10, 2023

Calliope Hummingbird Along With 2 Rufous at One Feeding Station, Polk County, NC, December 7, 2022

Although I’ve set up eBird Needs Alerts for a number of the nearby western NC counties, I don’t check them too often since there aren’t too many species reported that I still need for those county lists.  But luckily I checked my Polk County Needs Alert for November 23 – it contained a report of not only an adult male Rufous Hummingbird, but also an adult male and immature Calliope Hummingbird!  And all at the same feeding station!  More importantly, the Calliope would be an NC statebird for me.  Review of the photos posted on the eBird report revealed that what was initially ID’d as an immature Calliope was actually a Rufous/Allen’s – but the adult Calliope was still a good ID.

As is often the case for wintering hummingbirds at feeding stations, the key hurdle to overcome in chasing after them is gaining an invitation to visit those feeders.  And this time would be no different.  The person who first reported the birds was a bander that I knew, but he was apparently not at liberty to invite others to see the birds.  Then came reports on November 27 that birders were allowed to band the hummingbirds, but only 1 Rufous was present.  Although I’d still love to add the Rufous to my Polk County list, I was less interested in pushing the issue since there was no longer the potential for a statebird at the site.  Or was it…

On December 3rd I got word that the Calliope was back.  Now I needed an invitation to visit the home the hummingbirds were visiting.  Three local birders accompanied the bander on the 27th (Kevin Burke, Simon Thompson, and Vicky Burke), and I knew all three of them well.  They figured out a way to get invites, so perhaps they could get me an invitation as well.  I reached out to all three and found out that the homeowner was not generally willing to allow birders to visit, but since she had birded with those local birders in the past she was OK for them to come to her yard.  All 3 of my friends still needed the Calliope so they likely had an interest in coming back for another try.  Perhaps I could join them.  Sure enough, Vicky offered to meet me there on the 4th.  Unfortunately, I was leading a bird walk for the NC Bird Atlas that day so was not available.  As it turns out they were lucky enough to see the Calliope on the 4th but dipped on both Rufous.

Now I had to grovel some more to try for another invitation.  Just as I suspected Kevin and Simon wanted to see the Calliope as well, and planned another visit for December 7th – and I could come along.  The plan was to arrive at first light to be there when the hummingbirds started their feeding activity for the day.  We were all set – now we just needed the hummingbirds cooperate.

We carpooled to the homeowners residence and arrived just before 7 AM.  Simon and Kevin pointed out that there were three feeders that the hummingbirds were visiting – one on the front porch, one on the back of the house, and one on the side.  Plus, they often fed on pineapple sage flowers still in bloom in this garden near the driveway out back.  

We had only been there a couple minutes before we heard the characteristic hummingbird chipping notes at the pineapple sage.  It was still too dark for IDs, but we were optimistic.  Then we saw one hummingbird fly over our heads toward the side yard – we were up to 2 birds.  A few minutes later it was light enough to see the immature Rufous/Allen’s at the pineapple sage.  And a bit later I briefly spotted the adult Rufous at the side feeder.  But soon thereafter all was quiet.

Now that the initial flurry of activity was over we needed a game plan to find the Calliope.  Where the 3 feeders were located meant we could only see one at a time.  So we decided to split up and each of us focus on just one feeder.  I chose the one in the back of the house because I could also see the pineapple sage from there.  The 3 of us took up our posts and waited for our key target Calliope to appear. 

But with each passing minute with no hummingbird sightings at all I grew less and less optimistic.  We had now been there at least 45 minutes with no Calliope even though the Rufous were active at least at dawn.  Then Simon poked his head around the corner and said he had the Calliope.  I notified Kevin and we all converged on the front of the house.  Simon said the Calliope had just visited the feeder on the front porch and had flown to a small pine tree nearby.  With a bit of a search we spotted the adult male Calliope nicely perched in the pine right in front of the trunk.  Here’s my barely passable digi-binned photo of my target bird.  Sure was glad I was able to get an invite… 

Calliope Hummingbird was #322 for my NC statelist.  My statebird map for this species is inserted below.  The blue-shaded states are those where I’ve seen this species in its regular range.  Cross-hatched Oregon is the only one in its regular range where I have yet to see it.  And now NC is the 7th state (shaded in brown) where I’ve seen Calliope as a rarity.


 

Sunday, November 20, 2022

Another Rare Phalarope in Western NC, Lake Julian, Asheville, NC, October 24, 2022

It was early on October 24th when this text came across the Blue Ridge Audubon text group –

“Phalarope species at Julian just now”

Any Phalarope in the western NC mountains would be a rarity.  And this time of year the most likely species would be either a Red-necked or even a rarer Red.  I needed both species for my Buncombe County list, and better yet I needed Red Phalarope for my NC state list.  So within minutes I was out the door to chase after the still unidentified rarity. 

I was part way along my 25-minute drive to Lake Julian when the next text came across –

“We’re leaning Red…bird is pretty distant but the bill looks too thick”

At that point I pushed the accelerator down a bit harder.  The 25-minute drive seemed like 25 hours.

Along the ride I mentally reviewed the salient fieldmarks to separate the Phalarope species.  I’ve seen quite a number of Red and Red-necked Phalaropes over the years, including hundreds on pelagic trips when they were often distant birds either foraging on the ocean surface or flying by in flocks.  In non-breeding plumage the most important field mark on those distant birds is the mantle color – solid gray on a Red, and streaked gray and black on Red-necked.  Bill length and thickness are also good fieldmarks, but the slightly shorter and slightly thicker bill of a Red Phalarope are less likely to be noticeable on a distant bird, though of course that would eliminate a Wilson’s.

When I finally pulled into Lake Julian the first thing I saw was 2 birders standing at their cars.  My heart sunk as my first thought was that the Phalarope had flown away and the birders had given up.  Instead, they were just heading out after long views of the bird and other birders were still on it.  Crisis averted.  A minute later I was at the shoreline with 3 other birders watching the distant Phalarope.  I shared my ID details with the other birders who had limited if any experience with these species, and started my own review of the bird.

The Phalarope was perhaps 75 to 100 yards out on the lake, which sure complicates the ID on an 8-inch-long bird.  Luckily the water was smooth as glass and there was no heat shimmer.  It was actively foraging, rapidly picking at morsels on the surface, with frequent spinning along the way.  Classic Phalarope activity.  And the bill was short and thick.  Now to concentrate on the mantle.  The sun seemed to be washing out the bird, but the back did indeed appear to be pale and uniform.  Though there were a couple darker feathers in the folded wings.  A bit later the bird swam more to the west changing the sun angle, giving even a better look at the mantle – truly looked uniform gray.  It seemed good for a Red Phalarope, but it sure would be nice to have a closer look.

After I left, three birders rented a paddle boat and were able to paddle right up to the bird getting great looks confirming the ID as a Red Phalarope.  It was likely a juvenile bird still molting into its first winter plumage.

Per eBird, there were 3 previous records of Red Phalarope in western NC – the most recent of which was in 2004.  Interestingly, all 3 were in Transylvania County.  In two of these older records it was noted in the eBird checklist that the bird was seen right after wind and rainstorms, which is typical for inland Phalarope records.  But you certainly couldn’t attribute the Lake Julian bird to a storm event – we were in the middle of a mild drought with no rain for several weeks.  Just a bird passing through I guess.  Another surprising migrant for the NC mountains.  In fact, I’ve seen all 3 Phalarope species in western NC since I moved to the area in 2019.

Red Phalarope was #321 for my NC state list.  NC is now my 11th state with all 3 Phalaropes.

My statebird map for Red Phalarope is inserted below.  The blue states are those where I’ve seen this species in its regular coastal range and as a breeder in AK.  Cross-hatched Oregon is the last state in its regular range where I’ve yet to see it.  The seven brown states are those where I’ve seen it as an inland rarity. 


 

Sunday, February 20, 2022

7 NC Statebirds in First Half of NC/VA Coastal Trip Including Heermann's Gull and Other Nice Rarities, February 14-15, 2022

The Carolina Bird Club (CBC) had originally scheduled its January 2022 meeting for the NC Outer Banks.  But the Omicron Covid variant had other ideas.  Unfortunately, Covid numbers started to peak just before the meeting, and the CBC not surprisingly cancelled the meeting.  I was really looking forward to the guided field trips, not only to bird the coast, but to also learn about how to bird the area in general.  But if the Covid numbers dropped quickly, maybe I could squeeze in a trip to the coast on my own, perhaps in late February. 

And just as I had hoped, the numbers did indeed improve into February.  So I started to plan a 4-day trip to both the upper NC coast as well as southeastern VA.  Given the long travel times to get to the coast that would give me 2 full days of birding at the coast but just a couple hours on the travel days.  It turned out that I was free February 14 to 17, which lined up nicely with some dry but chilly weather.  This was starting to come together.

Then came the research into possible statebirds.  There were a few rarities being seen in both states, along with a number of regular species I still needed for my state lists.  After quite a bit of research I came up with the following tentative itinerary –

·       2/14 – travel to the NC coast, with afternoon birding at the Alligator NWR for an elusive Ash-throated Flycatcher, along with Golden Eagle and Rough-legged Hawk that were occasionally reported

·       2/15 – birding on the OBX starting with a seawatch at Cape Point, then time searching for a recently reported Snowy Owl near the Oregon Inlet campground, then another seawatch at Jennette’s Pier

·       2/16 – an action-packed day in southeastern VA with stops for a number of stakeouts (Bullock’s Oriole, Brewer’s Blackbird, Iceland Gull, and Common Eider) along with a seawatch at Ruddee Inlet, searches for Vesper Sparrows in Northampton County, and ending the day for Woodcocks at Eastern Shore of VA NWR

·       2/17 – a seawatch at dawn at Little Island Park before starting the drive home

But then as I was just about to finalize my plans came a report of a Mountain Bluebird in Wrightsville Beach– a 2nd state record.  The bird was first spotted on Friday (2/11) and continued reliably into the weekend.  And then on the 12th came a report of the 1st state record of Heermann’s Gull foraging in Mason Inlet at the northern end of Wrightsville Beach, just 10 minutes from the Bluebird.  And this was also the area where Long-tailed Ducks, another of my targets, had been recently reported. 

Wrightsville Beach was much farther south than I was planning to travel, but how could I skip those super-rarities?  I briefly considered changing the whole trip to visit the southern NC coast (including Wrightsville Beach) and the northern SC coast instead of heading north.  But then I wondered if I could start my trip with stops at Wrightsville Beach, then head north to still follow the rest of my original plan.  It would mean less time at each planned stop, but if the birds cooperated, I could squeeze it all in. 

Then there was one last complication – although the Bluebird continued to the 13th, the Heermann’s was not re-found that day despite many people searching.  But I figured the Bluebird and Long-tailed Ducks were still worth the extra travel time, so I kept with my revised plan.  And with that itinerary I hoped for perhaps 4 or 5 new statebirds in each state.

This blog post summarizes the NC portion of my trip. The VA portion is summarized in the next post.

February 14 – Wrightsville Beach

The first stop was the tiny island of habitat on an island just off Wrightsville Beach being visited by the Mountain Bluebird.  The entire area measured less than an acre and a half, consisting of a couple parking lots, a few trees, two small buildings, and a boat launch, with numerous telephone wires overhead.  And the bird had been seen perched on all of these features except the buildings.  The Bluebird had been reported that morning, so I was cautiously optimistic. 

I pulled into the parking lot around noon and was surprised to be the only birder there – I guess I’d have to find the bird on my own.  While the car was rolling to a stop I noticed a small bird perched on one of the cedars, but it was just a Yellow-rumped Warbler.  So I got out of the car to look around and not 10 seconds later noticed a bird perched on the wires – I had the Mountain Bluebird!  That was easy (statebird #1).  I took this phonescoped picture of this most cooperative bird. 

What a beautiful bird!  As I write this blog post the bird is still being seen in this same little area.

My statebird map for Mountain Bluebird is inserted below.  The states where I’ve seen this species in its regular range are shaded in blue.  Cross-hatched OK is the last state where I’ve yet to find it as a regular species.  And now NC is the 5th state where I’ve seen Mountain Bluebird as a rarity (shaded in tan). 

Since the Heermann’s Gull hadn’t been seen for two days I decided to not give it a try, and instead began to focus on my next target - Long-tailed Duck.  One had been seen recently at the Johnny Mercer Pier at Wrightsville Beach, and up to 7 had been seen at Masonboro Inlet at the south end of the island.  I figured my chances would be better looking for a small flock of birds, so I headed off to the inlet.  In any case I needed to find them quickly so I still had time to get to Alligator NWR that day to try for my targets there.

After a 10-minute drive, and a short walk through the dunes, I arrived at the inlet.  The Long-tails had been seen near the north jetty as recently as yesterday, though there were no reports today.  Several other birders were set up with scopes peering out into the inlet when I arrived.  No one had yet found the Long-tailed Ducks, though they had found 3 Great Cormorants and a large flock of 34 Purple Sandpipers.  Nice birds for NC, but not my target.  I searched the north jetty extensively, then searched the inlet and the more distant south jetty, but to no avail. 

Should I call it quits at the inlet and head back to the pier to try there?  Then I realized we were all only looking at the south side of the north jetty.  If we walked up the beach just a short distance we could see the north side of the jetty.  Seemed to be worth the try.  And sure enough, I set up the scope on the north side of the jetty and quickly picked up a flock of 5 Long-tailed Ducks swimming close to the jetty (statebird #2).  Just 3 more states to go to see it in its regular range.

That took a little longer than I hoped, but I still had enough time to make the drive to Alligator NWR and bird there for an hour or so before sunset.  However, when I got to the refuge at about 5 PM, the temperatures had dropped into the upper 30’s and it was quite breezy.  Not the best conditions to try to find a Flycatcher.  I scoured the area for maybe a half hour, but not surprisingly didn’t find the Ash-throated.  Plus I didn’t have a chance to get to the agricultural fields where my target raptors might be.  I would have to revise my schedule the next day to get back to the refuge with more time.  At least I had a pretty good handle on how to bird the area where the Ash-throated Flycatcher was being seen.

February 15 – Outer Banks, Alligator NWR

My first stop of the day was at Cape Point to do an extended seawatch.  In the last week one birder had been doing nearly daily seawatches at the Point finding tremendous numbers of nearly every species one might expect, and some spectacular species including 5 that would be new for my statelist like Razorbill, Parasitic Jaeger, Manx Shearwater, Little Gull, and Black-legged Kittiwake.  Plus loafing flocks of gulls near the point sometimes included an Iceland and a Glaucous Gull.  Needless to say, it was a target-rich environment, though I thought I’d be lucky to get just 2 or 3.

I drove to the end of Lighthouse Road near the Point, and at sunrise parked my car at the end of the pavement.  Then I “layered-up” and started my mile-long walk in the soft sand to the Point.  Here’s a look at sunrise along the way.

As I headed south there was lots of activity over the ocean with birds flying by both northbound and southbound.  But rather than stop along the way I headed right toward a large gull flock on the beach near the Point.  Unfortunately, neither white-winged gull was there, though it was nice to see dozens of Lesser Black-backs. 

Then I looked toward the Point and noticed a birder standing on a small sand dune scoping the ocean.  I made my way over to him to join him in the seawatch.  It turns out he was the birder who had done all those recent seawatches, Daniel Irons.  He had driven to the Point getting there a bit before me, though I hadn’t missed anything special.  Here’s the view from the top of our dune looking south.

Although this unmagnified picture may not look too spectacular, the ocean was actually alive with birds, featuring large flocks of Gannets, Forster’s Terns, Bonaparte’s Gulls, Red-throated Loons, and Double-crested Cormorants passing by and feeding not too far offshore.  There was also a flock of gulls just a short distance away at the outflow from Salt Pond but once again my target white-winged gulls were not mixed in.  Soon after I arrived Daniel spotted a Little Gull going by – unfortunately I never got on it.  I watched flocks of Bonaparte’s passing by for the next 30 minutes hoping the Little Gull might return but never spotted it.  That was frustrating. 

During one of the slower times I looked back over to the gull flock and instantly spotted an all gray gull with a white head and red bill flying in – I had re-found the Heermann’s Gull!  (statebird #3)  It was last seen 3 days earlier at Wrightsville Beach, some 145 miles away as the Gull flies.  I got this phonescoped photo of the bird standing behind a Ring-billed Gull.

Unfortunately, it only stayed about 10 minutes before it took off heading east disappearing over the ocean.  In the last year I’ve now seen this Pacific Ocean species in GA, VA, and now NC.  Wonder what’s causing it to show up on the Atlantic coast.

With that excitement behind us we turned our interest back to the seawatch.  Activity had slowed quite a bit after the first 90 minutes or so, but some good birds were still passing by.  Daniel spotted a couple Razorbills and this time I was able to pick them up (statebird #4).  And a bit later I was also able to find a Manx Shearwater that Daniel had picked up (statebird #5).  NC was my 6th state for this species which is regular through most of the Atlantic coast, though not often seen from shore.

Manx map

After about 3 hours on the point I decided to end my seawatch, very happy to have seen 3 new statebirds, including re-finding the Heermann’s Gull.  On the way back I ran into 3 very tame “Ipswich” Savannah Sparrows feeding in the sand - a nice ending for this spot and a welcome break during the long walk in soft sand.

My planned next stop was near the Oregon Inlet Campground to try for a recently reported Snowy Owl.  Unfortunately it had not been reported for 3 days, and since I needed to get back to Alligator NWR, I decided to pass on this low probability target and headed right to the refuge.  Though I certainly kept my eyes open as I passed through the area.  (It turns out that the bird was not seen again after the 12th so I made the right decision.)

I rolled into Alligator NWR at about 12:30 and went right to the western end of Sawyer Lake Rd to search for the Ash-throated Flycatcher.  It had been reported that morning so I was hopeful, but there were also many negative reports over the last several days.  There were only a few reports that mentioned the location of the bird, and all described it as being on the north side of the road along a canal that paralleled the road.  One report mentioned it was with a Phoebe, and another included pictures of the bird eating sumac berries.  I spent nearly 2 hours at this location without seeing the bird.  Though I found a couple Phoebes, sumac berries, and even a Phoebe eating the sumac berries. 

Then I remembered one report saying it responded to taped calls.  I started playing some tape and after a while got a bird to call back several times in response.  It gave a “breep” or perhaps “peek” call which certainly sounded flycatcher-like but was unlike the calls I was playing.  I told myself I’d have to listen to other recordings to see what I was hearing.  That night I went onto the Xeno-canto website and there were many recordings of this call note from Ash-throated Flycatcher.  In fact, there were more of these calls than those similar to the taped calls I was playing in the field.  Here’s a link to the calls on the website-

https://xeno-canto.org/species/Myiarchus-cinerascens

Although I sure wish I had seen the bird, I was confident that I had heard the Ash-throated Flycatcher (statebird #6).  This bird which is principally found in the southwest is prone to vagrancy, and I’ve now added it to my lists in 6 eastern states plus KS.

Then I was off to the ag fields in Alligator NWR where there had been occasional reports of a Rough-legged Hawk, and a few older reports of Golden Eagle.  I was running out of time but spent perhaps a half hour driving along the fields looking for raptors.  I had good numbers of Harriers, Red-tails, and Vultures, but none of my targets.  Though a hovering buteo that turned out to be a Red-tail sure got my attention for a while.  (Ironically later in the day I had a Rough-legged Hawk just across the state line in VA – but I don’t need it in VA.)  And a long-staying Sandhill Crane was nice.  I wanted to stay longer but still planned to do a seawatch from Jennette’s Pier, so I needed to move on.  Unfortunately, I was still paying the price for adding that diversion to Wrightsville Beach.

I rolled into Jennette’s Pier at about 3 PM – lighting and visibility were excellent so now I just needed the birds to cooperate. 

The pier sticks some 900 feet out into the ocean so seabirds can sometimes be pretty close.  At first it was quite slow with just a few Forster’s Terns passing by and both Red-throated and Common Loons on the water.  Then I noticed a Razorbill flying north, then another, and then a small flock.  Over the next 45 minutes I counted 14 flying by, and 2 very distant alcid flocks numbering 42 birds that were probably Razorbills but I entered them as “large alcid sp.”  Then I picked up a group of 3 Razorbills on the water not too far offshore.  While watching them another much smaller alcid flew through my scope field.  I watched it for a couple seconds until it dropped to the water and disappeared in the swells.  It was like a football with rapidly beating wings, with a short neck and small head and bill.  I had found a Dovekie! (statebird #7). 

What a great way to end the NC portion of my trip!  Although I was more than a bit rushed at times, I’m glad I added the side-trip to Wrightsville Beach.  And with 7 new birds that brings my NC list to 320.  The link to the eBird Trip report for this NC portion of my coastal trip is inserted below-

https://ebird.org/tripreport/39063

I could only hope to have similar successes in Virginia!

(My next post summarizes the VA portion of my trip.)

Sunday, January 16, 2022

Western Grebe, Cabarrus County, NC, January 1, 2022

My NC Needs Alert on 12/27 featured multiple reports of a Western Grebe on Lake Norman north of Charlotte, NC.  Then likely the same bird was re-located the next day on Coddle Creek Reservoir in Cabarrus County some 6 or 7 miles to the east.  That’s one I need for my NC list, and within my typical chase distance.  Now I just needed the bird to stick around till January 1 – the first day I was available.  That would be a great way to ring in the new birding year.   

My experience with wintering Western Grebes in the northeast is that they will often stay in protected lakes and bays for quite a while.  And luckily that was the case with this bird as it continued to be reported daily.  The good news was that it was often seen in the same part of the reservoir.  The bad news was that it was almost always quite distant – perhaps a mile or more away.  My birding friend Bill Hooker went to see it on the 30th, and he shared his notes with me including the best viewing spot (which interestingly was only mentioned in 1 eBird post).  Plus he offered to meet me there on the 1st which would be most helpful.  The trip was set!

I pulled in at 1 PM and Bill and Anita were already there.  They had scoped the area the Grebe preferred but hadn’t found it yet.  That was mostly because that part of the reservoir was full of birds, most notably perhaps 3,500 Ring-billed Gulls.  There were also 50 ducks on the far shore that were just too far away to identify.  This was going to be difficult. 

I scanned the area multiple times but just kept finding the same birds.  It had been nearly an hour without success when the entire flock of gulls took off, perhaps spooked by an Eagle.  With the gulls temporarily off the water, I hoped that my target bird would be much easier to find - that is if it wasn’t spooked as well.  And sure enough on my first scan through the area I picked out the Western Grebe close to the far shore.  We watched it slowly swim along before it mixed with the distant ducks and disappeared behind a nearby point.

Here is an unmagnified picture of the area where we saw the grebe, perhaps 1.2 miles away. 


And a relative “close-up” of the duck flock it mixed with for a while.

Western Grebe was #312 for my NC state list.  My statebird map for this species is inserted below – in its regular range the blue states are those where I’ve seen this species and the cross-hatched states are those where I still need it. And given that Western Grebe is prone to vagrancy, it’s not surprising that NC was the 8th state where I’ve seen Western Grebe as a rarity (the tan states). 

As an aside – This was not the first time I’ve seen a Western Grebe a mile or more away.  In April 2016 I was able to re-find a Western Grebe on a coastal bay in Brunswick, ME where the bird was roughly 6,500 ft away.  (see my blog post - State Birding: Western Grebe, Brunswick, ME, April 2016 ).One local birder said the bird was “wicked faahh out”.  Needless to say birders’ viewing the NC bird had quite a different accent.

What a great way to start 2022!